Oceania vs Regent
I've sailed RSSC 3-4 times now and like the product, even the one time the ship we were on (Voyager) crashed into the pier in Civitavecchia and made us miss our Pompeii excursion!.
BUT
I'm really not sure if the RSSC value proposition works as well for us anymore especially since they got rid of the included business class airfare for international. And now that Oceania is adult only, that is a HUGE plus for us. We never really ran into kids on RSSC that were a problem but it is certainly not impossible especially on cruises over the holidays or week long in the Caribbean. Oceania seems to capture 90% of what we like with Regent, and we've met a few people on RSSC that said they actually preferred Oceania.
For those of you that sailed both, I'd like an honest pro/con between the lines? I really like the open bars on RSSC but to be honest most of the drinks we have are nothing fancy, wine and mix cocktails. Perhaps the odd highball but the requirements are not top-shelf by any means. Thinking about Panama Canal, *maybe* Trans-Pacific but this is still super early days.