Creatine - Via Negativa
I already know what the criticisms of this post will be:
“It’s n=1.”
“The plural of anecdote is not data.”
“That’s called the placebo effect.”
Don’t care.
But before we go into it, let’s set the groundwork.
Background
I started taking creatine at Uni in the mid to late 90s.
Back then the guidelines were loading phase (25g per day for the first 5 days, and always with grape juice) and then 5g maintenance.
The focus was on the physical benefits.
Fast forward to 2005 when I was asked to write a position stand on creatine and read, summarised and processed about 70 studies on the amino acid.
And I’ve been recommending it professionally since about 2001. My international tennis players were using it for travel fatigue and jet lag from about 2008; my extreme sport athletes used it for concussions (traumatic brain injuries) since 2013 and my perimenopausal clients have been using it for brain fog since 2016.
Point is, I have an understanding on how it works, the safety profile and benefits.
The Cycle
My belief is anything that is taken at above-natural-levels can produce (unknown?) side effects at above-natural-levels.
So I exercise some caution - I cycle (or periodise) my creatine
Typically, it’s a 6 week on, 1 to 2 weeks off cycle.
This off-cycle has been the longest (3 weeks) because the on-cycle has been the longest.
(When you have a supplement company it’s sometimes easier to be in the on-cycle than the off-cycle : )
Effects
Well, have I noticed the difference!
Not physically - about to turn 48 and am not pushing any physical boundaries : )
Cognitively!
Little things, but noticeable.
Emails without attachments. Forgetting about meetings (until the reminder pops up). Doubling up on orders (because I’d forgotten I’d already done that).
Just not as sharp as I feel I can be.
Sure, it could be my age… But it’s synced perfectly with this off-cycle (see criticism 3 in the first paragraph).
Coincidence?
Just this morning I was chatting to an NRL coach about sponsoring a national team and the topic of creatine came up.
He too can feel the difference when he is off it (and he only goes off one week at a time).
Via Negativa
It seems that we might notice the cognitive benefits of creatine less when we cycle on (some studies suggests it could be as long as 4 weeks to notice the effects on the brain in TBI patients), and more when we cycle off.
Anyway, over to you - how does it affect you?