r/PrivateInternetAccess

Switching to Proton VPN  (PIA vs Proton)
▲ 20 r/PrivateInternetAccess+1 crossposts

Switching to Proton VPN (PIA vs Proton)

Hi all, just thought I'd share my experience in case it helps someone else...

I have been with PIA for almost 6 years now and recently I have been having speed issues and also changes to how they handle port forwarded connections.

I only had 2 months left before I was going to renew for 3 years and thought I'd try out proton as it is reviewed very highly, and it did not disappoint.

PIA using their "Optimal connection" Halved my internet speed, Proton on the other hand allows me to use almost max connection speeds.

No VPN (899 Download, 80 Upload)
https://imgur.com/a/Eg6EqSi#GCHLATv

PIA VPN (402 Down, 75 Up)
https://imgur.com/a/Eg6EqSi#TxBzbmS

Proton VPN (834 Down, 73 Up)
https://imgur.com/a/Eg6EqSi#WwNdws4

PIA has served me well but it is time to move on as Proton's port-forwarded connections are much easier to use and they also offer email services among other things.

u/Z3dan — 16 hours ago

Speed issue

Hi! I ran 5 different speed tests without PIA and the results are below. When I enable PIA and pick the closest server to me (New York) I'm getting 63 Mbps download at best and 6 Mbps upload. That's a far cry from  the 400+ to 500+ Mbps download I get without it. I understand I will lose some speed with a VPN, but that much? 400 Mbps less? Some tests oddly showed better upload speeds than download speeds such as 26 Mbps download and 96 Mbps upload. What gives?

Without PIA enabled...

https://www.speedtest.net
Download Mbps 542.73
Upload Mbps 85.73

https://fiber.google.com/speedtest/
Download 517.0 Mbps
Upload 87.1Mbps

https://fast.com/#
Your Internet speed is 560 Mbps
Upload Speed 84 Mbps

https://speed.cloudflare.com/
Download: 465 Mbps
Upload: 66.4 Mbps

https://wifiman.com/
Download: 551.13Mbps
Upload: 92.53Mbps

u/Paul65890 — 1 day ago

PSA: PIA Chrome Extension works again

After a back-and-forth with PIA support over a few weeks, they eventually came back to me on Saturday asking me to update the Chrome extension to version 5.

I can confirm that it works after updating.

reddit.com
u/Ho3n3r — 1 day ago

Is PIA down now?

It won't connect and when I suspected maybe my account expired, I tried to make a payment, and when I was submitting creddit card info, it consistently said "Your credit card expiration date is in the past" when I was putting in a 2027 date. Did this in both Chrome and Edge. So I can't renew.

reddit.com
u/Duotrigordle61 — 2 days ago

Reyee/Ruijie router - does anyone know how to set it up for PIA?

I've tried 3 different router brands that are all supposed to be good for PIA, but the routers, themselves, are problematic.
For regular internet, our Reyee E5 is the best I've found, but their VPN instructions are clear as mud.
Anyone had any experience putting PIA on a Reyee?

reddit.com
u/andonandonandonando — 2 days ago
▲ 11 r/PrivateInternetAccess+5 crossposts

BibaVPN: A DPI-resistant tunnel in Rust. TLS + WebSocket muxing with per-frame padding.

I've been working on a tunneling solution designed to bypass active probing and traffic analysis in restrictive environments. It's fully open-source (MIT) and written in pure Rust.

The Stack & Architecture:
- Transport: Wraps SOCKS5/HTTP-CONNECT into TLS + WebSocket.
- Multiplexing: Multiple streams over a single long-lived WebSocket connection to minimize TLS handshake fingerprints.
- Anti-DPI: Uses a shared-PSK layer (BibaV2) and per-frame random padding to obfuscate traffic patterns
- Camouflage: Support for HTTP decoy/camouflage on the same port
- Fingerprinting: Implementation of browser-ordered TLS upgrade headers (using a uTLS-like approach in the biba crate).

Why this instead of X? I wanted something that looks like standard HTTPS/WSS traffic to an outside observer, but provides full control over the frame padding and TLS hello. No proprietary "black box" protocols б just standard primitives used to hide the tunnel.

It’s still experimental, so I’m looking for feedback on the protocol spec and the multiplexing implementation.

Repo: https://github.com/Eljaja/BibaVPN
Protocol Details: Check PROTOCOL.md in the root.

u/OtherwiseRecipe2356 — 3 days ago

Will connect, but won’t change IP

I’m by no means a tech savvy guy. I honestly kinda suck at this stuff. But I have been using PIA for over a year now and it’s always worked perfectly. On my computer it still works and changes my ip, but on iOS it doesn’t.

No matter what server I click, anywhere in the USA, or other countries, it “connects” me, but does not change my actual ip, and the “VPN ip” area underneath my server selection is completely blank. I’ve tried changing to like 10-15 different servers over the last few days, tried changing some settings, and I’m completely lost at what to do. My subscription is still active until November as well.

If anyone could give me some insight on how to fix this on IOS, it would be greatly appreciated. Thank you.

reddit.com
u/LilWindex3004 — 2 days ago

PIA and Facebook Auto-banning

Anybody else have this issue? Facebook is predatory and I want to use a VPN. But as soon as I connect to PIA I get auto-banned, even after submitting video selfies for ID confirmation.

Does anyone have a working solution without abandoning PIA?

reddit.com
u/False-Tadpole-86 — 6 days ago

I made a lighter, better behaved macOS client for PIA

I'm tired of the "your network preferences prevent content from loading privately" error in Mail.app along with PIA breaking iCloud Private Relay and other issues, so I made a lightweight native SwiftUI client that doesn't have these issues. It supports WireGuard and OpenVPN, it supports port forwarding, and it's fully open source.

You can download it from https://github.com/ptaru/PrivateClient/releases or do brew install --cask ptaru/tap/privateclient.

Is this free?

Yes.

Is this safe?

Yes, and the source is fully available for you to inspect.

What's missing?

No "kill switch", no dedicated IP support. I don't use these things, so I didn't bother with them.

Why is this Tahoe-only?

Because I wanted to use liquid glass, as you can see in the screenshot. It should be fairly trivial to modify the source to make it compile on Sequoia, but macOS versions earlier than that require swapping out some APIs which would be more work.

Did you use AI tools?

Yes, because a VPN client is the exact kind of thing that AI turns into a fun side project rather than a large undertaking consisting of tedious integration work. I think it's a no brainer for something like this. I left my AGENTS.md in the repo for any contributors.

What's the license?

GPLv3, because this uses the Partout library to handle the actual connections.

u/_ptaru — 5 days ago

Is PIA ever going to fix its chrome extension?

The Chrome extension is broken and has two main issues. First, the feature to always stay active does not work at all. Second, while using it, the extension randomly disconnects and prompts me with a dialogue box to re-enter my credentials. I have to use a different VPN extension provided by my Usenet provider to get the access I need. I would prefer to use PIA if their extension worked properly.

reddit.com
u/gutty976 — 8 days ago

version 3.5.7 for macOS

The app used to update frequently, but it has been a long time since I got an update. I’m not interested in moving to a beta version, but if that meant a more secure connection, I’d probably consider it. The fact that the app hasn’t been patched yet makes me wary of using it, seeing as it’s more likely to be somehow compromised.

What are your experiences and what do you recommend? To be fair, the app runs okay, but I’m still a bit worried for the reasons I stated above.

PS: I’m running PIA on an old Mac running Monterey.

reddit.com
u/jakobkiefer — 5 days ago

Is there maybe a vpn that kind of removes logging completely?

I might be wrong here, and I am not saying this applies to every vpn, but it seems like most of them probably still have the ability to access traffic even if they say they do not log, which is maybe fine in some cases but also kind of depends on trust a lot.

So I am wondering if there js possibly a vpn that maybe removes that capability entirely, not just in theory but actually in practice, though I could be misunderstanding how these systems are designed.

reddit.com
u/Flimsy-Zone-1430 — 8 days ago

ISP, IPTV, privacy

Hi! I currently use PIA VPN.

My ISP has a TV service, but that TV service does not carry and will never carry some sports channels I need to watch. Because of this I have decided to look at IPTV services. I plan on cancelling my TV service to go with IPTV and wanted to know about privacy in this situation. How can I prevent my ISP from seeing that I'm using/connecting to a IPTV service? Would DNS over TLS in my router settings be of any help? Help with this is appreciated! Thank you!

reddit.com
u/Paul65890 — 10 days ago

PIA VPN and IPTV

Does anyone has experience using PIA with IPTV providers? Currently i have PIA and another well known VPN brand. The other VPN has some servers that work fine with my IPTV provider, the PIA servers seem not work with the IPTV provider.

Does any of you, know if PIA has working configurations for IPTV?

reddit.com
u/Jealous-Weekend4674 — 12 days ago

Will there be a refund or discount for the chrome downtime?

Its been like 25 days with the chrome extension being broken. The reason for using PIA is because of the extension working on chromebooks. Kinda upset I paid for something and its not working.

reddit.com
u/x9x9x9x9x9 — 14 days ago

What's going on with Scandinavian IP addresses?

For years it seems most IPs in Sweden and Norway have started with 46.*.*.* or 212.*.*.* and belong to Glesys. Recently the Swedish IPs switched to 158.*.*.* and seem to belong to Datacamp Limited. I switched to Norway and they still had the usual Glesys IPs, but now I keep getting Datacamp 158.*.*.* from there too. Finland still seems to use Glesys for now.

Is PIA switching providers/ISP from Glesys to Datacamp in Scandinavian regions? Is it temporary? Anyone else noticed this or is it just me?

I'm using OpenVPN btw.

reddit.com
u/Green_Soup_1584 — 11 days ago

What settings could strangle bandwidth on port forwarding servers only?

Just trying to torrent things normally and, despite 600Mbps+ without PIA running, it consistently drops to 40-100Mbps when I'm connected. I've tried toggling basically all of the settings in the PC client to no avail, and the same issue seems to happen on my Android phone through any PIA servers when trying to torrent things. 5G connection or through the same home router as my PC, doesn't seem to make any difference.

BT client is QBitorrent 5.0.3, PIA is 3.6.1, build 08339. Hardwired to my router via gigabit. Tried clean installs of both the VPN client, though is there a definitive "clean sweep" method of uninstalling all traces of the client and reverting to 100% defaults? Doesn't seem to be my router, but are there any settings that could be crippling my bandwidth on it?

And just to be clear here, sufficiently-seeded torrents completely saturate my bandwidth if I turn QBT to "any interface" to the point where the lack of bandwidth on other devices on the network is noticeable. So it's not like my modem or router are physically dying. I tried torrenting a few different massive Unix distros repeatedly and for ~30m straight, the hardware worked just fine at max speed.

Edit - does uPNP need to specifically be enabled/disabled? That seemed to be causing issues previously until I turned it off (hence the need for the port forwarding-enabled servers), but then it regressed back to this.

reddit.com
u/silentrawr — 14 days ago