Middle school typing is too late and too early at the same time and we've somehow made it nobody's job
Here is the bind we're in with keyboarding in middle school and I want someone to tell me I'm wrong because I've been sitting with this for a while.
Elementary says middle school will handle it. Middle school says elementary should have handled it. High school says they can't believe neither of the others handled it. And the kid in the middle of all of this is hunting and pecking their way through a timed essay in eighth grade while we all look at each other and shrug.
The "too early" argument is that seven year olds don't have the fine motor development for serious keyboarding instruction and you'll just build frustration. The "too late" argument is that by middle school students have already developed bad habits so deeply ingrained that retraining them takes longer than teaching it from scratch would have.
Both of those things can be true simultaneously and they both conveniently mean it's someone else's problem.
What actually happens in middle school is that teachers have thirty other curriculum priorities, keyboarding doesn't have a grade attached to it, nobody is being evaluated on whether students can type, and so it just doesn't happen in any systematic way except maybe a two-week unit in sixth grade computer class that everyone forgets by March.
I'm not saying I have the answer. I'm saying we've collectively constructed a situation where nobody owns this skill and then we're surprised when students don't have it.