r/Marxism

On This Day in History: Enver Hoxha Dies
▲ 18 r/Marxism

On This Day in History: Enver Hoxha Dies

​

On This Day in History: Enver Hoxha Dies

Enver Hoxha was an Albanian politician who led Albania as the First Secretary of the Party of Labour of Albania from 1944 until his death on this day (11 April) in 1985. Hoxha is most well known for, following the death of Mao Zedong in 1976, becoming the new face (after Mao) of anti-revisionist Marxism-Leninism across the communist world after criticising China for drifting to revisionism under Deng Xiaoping.

Even by anti-revisionist Marxist-Leninists, Hoxha is often viewed as a deeply flawed person. On one hand, Hoxha transformed Albania from an impoverished, deeply troubled nation occupied previously by fascist forces to a relatively modernized state which established excellent education, pretty decent healthcare, good women's rights, high electricity and power, ) good safety, and exceptionally low crime rates. On the other hand, Hoxha is remembered for his documented cult of personality, extreme paranoia which resulted in building thousands of bunkers across the country (an economic burden which was widely considered unjustified and extremely pointless even by leftists), brutal state atheism, and political oppression. This narrative isn't really \_as\_ exaggerated by Western media as well, unlike countries like DPRK or USSR which continue to face false slander.

Hoxha is most notable for his anti revisionism, as previously mentioned. Following Stalin's death, a leader which Hoxha deeply admired, Hoxha would withdraw Albania from the Warsaw Pact and side with China in the Sino-Soviet split, making him one of the only socialist leaders in the world to side with China and the only former Warsaw Pact member to do so. Albania continued to exist as a loyal ally to Mao Zedong and as an extreme opponent of revisionism and Khrushchev himself. From the Warsaw Pact withdraw in the late 1950s to the late 1970s, Hoxhaist Albania underwent many of the incredible, genuine achievements mentioned above but also undergoing state atheism and political oppression and a cult of personality which was increasingly intensifying. He is particularly condemned for state atheism, as he completely and somewhat violently persecuted religion in a Bolshevik-esque manner which is widely condemned today even by Hoxhaists.

In the 1970s, Hoxha's status as a Chinese ally transformed into opposition to the state his previously admired. As China drifted towards revisionism and turned westward, Hoxha realised that China was no longer a reliable anti revisionist ally, at least according to his eyes. Therefore, Albania also split from China in the late 1970s and became an isolated state which opposed and demonised every other country in the world. They were totally isolated and broken off from everyone, and all they had were themselves. Hoxha continued to lead Albania until his death in 1985, where Ramiz Alia then took over and then Albania fell with the rest of the Warsaw Pact, perhaps somewhat ironically.

So how's Hoxha remembered today? In Albania, especially by those who live under Hoxhaism, many do share a genuine fondness for the Hoxhaist era for providing security, safety and equality. However, especially in a significantly religious country, many genuinely have never forgiven state atheist policies and the isolation which occurred near the end of Hoxhas life. He's a deeply contradictory and polarising figure championed for showing the benefits of anti revisionist, "true" Marxism Leninism but also showing the dangers of dogmatic Marxism.

So let's turn the discussion to you. I write this as someone who is an anti revisionist socialist but I ultimately hold a complex view of Hoxha. What do you think of Enver Hoxha?

u/Vast-Lime-8457 — 8 hours ago
▲ 1 r/Marxism+1 crossposts

What it is like to be with a Marxist in a relationship?

He is a Marxist. Yesterday he suddenly told me that “he doesn’t trust monogamy because he thinks that it is a representation of private property. “

He said he won’t think if I am the one to cheat if I love more guys. Because he believes that a person can love multiple people in his or her life…

But I mean love or stepping in to a relationship means commitment. And also he told me that he will just let it be; and if he meet a new girl he will make the new girl and I become friends.

Moreover, in his words, since he has told me about this, so what he do is not considered as “cheat”.

For me, this is open relationship; and it is not about Marxism…

Is this a normal thing?

Please reply more in this post.

Thank you very much.

reddit.com
u/Reasonable-Gate-5867 — 3 hours ago
▲ 13 r/Marxism

Reading list

I’m starting a master’s in political economy in september, and I’m looking for book recs! I’m currently reading Capital Volume 1 and want to know what I should read next. I want to go in with a solid foundation so open to any suggestions. For context I did my bachelor’s in economics and have previously read some books on colonialism and inequality. Thanks!

reddit.com
u/Odd_Mix_8106 — 23 hours ago

Questions about unproductive labour in capitalism

Hi all,

Just started vol. 2, and reading marx' description of forms of unproductive labour as labour that is necessary for the capitalist process but does not produce surplus value. This can include salespeople, bookkeepers, managers etc. This makes sense to me in the internal aspects of the individual capital, but am having trouble grasping this on a wider level

For instance, supermarkets. A supermarket operates as a capital, employing wage labour to generate surplus value. However, no commodities are produced, and no value is created, merely a use value essentially equivalent to our aforementioned sales agents whose job is to move commodities thru the market. In this respect, a capital exists without productive labour. Likewise with accountancy firms, employment agencies, universities etc.

Maybe my questions will be answered later in vol. 2, but it doesn't quite make sense to me. Are these businesses not considered capital by Marx? Is the existence of such organizations just an extension of productive capital, acting as a parasite/siphon on value producing firms? Is a society that is majority nonproductive capitals still considered capitalist?

Thanks for any input.

reddit.com
u/EnsignStormtrooper — 20 hours ago

How is human transformation expected on the path to communism?

Not long ago I began to actively study Marxist-Leninist theory and one question is increasingly ripening in my mind:

Why, according to Marxist theory, during the transition to the highest stage of communism, is it expected that people will stop resorting to violence, will instinctively follow community norms and consciously work for its benefit, only on the basis of the cessation of class oppression? There are many other reasons for the emergence of violence, selfishness and other negative phenomena that Marx and Engels for some reason attribute to class tension, at a minimum the need for recognition is no lower than the need for work and does not fit into the image of the new man at all.

Due to the need for recognition, a person will in any case consciously violate norms in order to attract public attention to himself!

reddit.com
u/UwUBattleAlarm — 23 hours ago

How do you ensure the right people get into power in a revolution?

If there is ever a revolution, be it global or more localised in one of the larger western nations, how will the revolutionaries ensure that the right people get into power? Revolutions are times of great confusion thanks to the power vacuums they create, and so how will opportunists be prevented from seizing power?

reddit.com
u/Ok_Leader_6075 — 21 hours ago

Question: Has there been a true marxist commune/settlement in the world?

It got me thinking, were there any that had significance? I'm asking this question because, I'm doing research on true left-wing communes/settlements and I need some info about marxist ones.

reddit.com
u/Ok_Hospital3128 — 4 hours ago
Week