

Okay, Dodgers fans. Here’s a fun discussion. If you could bring back any Brooklyn-era player for the current team…
…who would that be?
I mean, let’s be honest here: it’s not like you guys need any help. As a Brewers fan since birth (but very much an admirer of the Dodgers and their rich history, and a lover of “the Boys of Summer”), I have to admit to being envious of how good your team is.
You’ve got a hell of a shot to three-peat, and while I’d like to get some payback after you put the beat down on my Brewers, and cost me my long hoped for trip back to the World Series (I’ve been waiting for forty-four years), the baseball lover in me can’t help but admirer how good you are. There’s a thrill that can only come with seeing the game played at the highest level. It’s poetry in motion.
Baseball….is like no other sport in the world. It’s my greatest passion. It’s a team game that lives and dies on the individual matchups. In the NFL, a quarterback can throw the ball forty times. Matthew Stanford, or Patrick Mahomes, can take over the game. In the NBA, a guy like Kobe Bryant or Steph Curry could conceivably shoot the ball every time they came down the court. Remember when Gretzky was on the Kings? He could put the puck on the goal every time he had a shift.
That can’t happen in baseball. If Shohei or Freddie are in a groove, they have to wait for eight other teammates to bat before they get another shot. Baseball is the ultimate chess match, a beautiful mixture of athleticism and intelligence. You guys have both in spades.
But looking at the team you have now…who would you bring back? This player has to have played at least part of one season while the team was still in Flatbush. We’ll jump in the old DeLorean, grab a couple of canisters of plutonium, get up to 88 mph, and snag on of “the bums” from their career peak.
Do you take a pitcher? Sandy Koufax or Don Drysdale? Don Newcomb? How about a guy that could spot start, or work as a long reliever like Carl Erskine? Do you grab Duke Snider to help add another power bat in the outfield while Mookie is healing up? Gil Hodges would be a real nice bat off the bench.
I’ve included some selections from my personal collection to whet your appetites for the discussion. A nice 1955 Topps Jackie, a number of 1909-‘11 T206 Dodger tobacco cards, a couple of 1965 Topps cards of Koufax and Drysdale, 1957 Topps examples from Pee Wee Reese and Gil Hodges, a 1953 Bowman Color “Oisk”, and a 1960 Topps of Duke Snider. And after I’d started putting stuff away, it dawned on me: I can’t have a discussion of the Brooklyn team without Roy Campanella, so I had to get one of his, too.
Let me know who you’d take, and what your thinking was behind the decision.