u/usavin

▲ 3 r/PakistaniHistory+1 crossposts

Heritage: Indus or Islam

(See Last 3 Paragraph)

There are two modern interpretations of what pakistans heritage should be.

One is Ancestry. That the pakistani people are the direct and only descendants of the people of sindh, punjab, balchistan, kpk and kashmir, and by extension the civillizations of indus mehrgarh and gandhara etc. Even today Dravidian languages are spoken in balchistan separate by thousands of miles from south india. Indians are Not related by blood or ancestry to indus or gandhara and try to claim it as their history under the pretext of "india one country" while their ancestors were directly at conflict with and had wars with our ancestors.

The Other is Religion. As the nation was created solely on the basis of religion and Two nation Theory, Islams heritage is our heritage. This means Pakistan is the spirtual success of every islamic nation and history in the subcontinent, Starting from Muhammad bin Qasim, The Ghaznavids, Delhi Sultanate, all the way to the Mughal Empire.

Now to the issue; Indians claim pakistans heritage of indus is invalid because by adopting an identity based on the religion of Islam , its severed from the Beliefs and Culture of Indus. However that is a paradox because if Culture and Heritage can be changed and denied by an identity formed on a Religion, you can simply deduce Culture and Heritage can be gained by an identity formed on Religion.

Thus If Pakistan Is not the heritage of its own ancestors because of a religious identity, then by that same logic Pakistan is the successor of states like the Ghaznavids, the Delhi sultanate or indeed the Mughal empire.

And if Pakistan is Not the successor of the Delhi Sultanate or the Mughal Empire because theyre not pakistan's ancestors or their lands dont lie in modern pakistans territory then by the same logic Pakistan is the Successor of Indus because theyre their ancestors And their lands lie in Pakistan, and indias just pretending.

I hope you see now that denying one of pakistans heritage directly enforces the other by the same logic. I've seen indians claim Indus as theirs because same culture and religion of the people (when by that same logic pakistan is the delhi sultanates successor) and in the same breath deny Pakistans Muslim heritage too. Pakistan was made by Muslims all over india who migrated there so Pakistan has a claim to all muslim kingdoms in india by that logic. I hope you understand the paradox.

reddit.com
u/usavin — 3 days ago
▲ 1 r/flags

Millitary Organizations in Kashmir

Army of the Righteous

Daughters of the Nation

Muhammads Legion

The Full Moon

Harkatul Mujahidin

Hizbul Mujahidin

Ansar Ghazwat Alhind

The Resistance Front

Peoples Antifa Front

Alumar Mujahidin

United Jihad Council

Lashkare Jhangvi

These militants have been propped up and controlled by Pakistans ISI some directly some through the United Jihad Council, following the death by thousand cuts philosophy albeit many of these organizations fight for independence from both india and pakistan, forming a secular (yes ik jihadis want a secular its ironic but true) and independent kashmir.

Im more intrigued by the diversity and the fantasy thing they have going.

Theres a secular one, a liberal one, a racist hyper sectarian one thats dangerous even to the others, even the token fantasy all female one

u/usavin — 4 days ago

Instrument of Accession

Instrument of accession of Junagadh and Manavadar, a hindu majority province in modern day Gujrat, India. It had a muslim nawab but a hindu populace. On 14 February 1949, the nawab of Junagadh signed the instrument of accession to join Pakistan. India however illegaly invaded it and seized control. If Kashmir belongs to india because of an instrument of accession by a hindu king in a muslim majority province ie kashmir, then Junagadh and Manavadar should belong to Pakistan as they signed the principle of accession to Pakistan.

u/usavin — 4 days ago

Concering hijabs (see body)

If cool hijabs are haram because they draw attention, and women drawing attention to themselves is haram, then does that mean Hijabs are haram in countries where theyre not common (eg france usa) because they draw negative attention? women there wear relatively skimpier clothing so wearing a hijab in nonmuslim countries is haram according to that logic as it draws undue attention from men

u/usavin — 4 days ago
▲ 120 r/flags

Britain, but Pakistan got there first

All those "britain got there first" flags pmo

u/usavin — 4 days ago

im an israeli goonslop artist and this is my art [oc]

whys nightcorey old animeish art so hard tho

u/usavin — 5 days ago

The Continent of Dinia and Pakasia

Choudhary Rehmat Ali made extensive plans for the partition of Pakistan and published numerous books and pamphlets for his cause. Theyve been notoriously hard to find (especially the post pakistan ones like "Pakistan or Pastan" or "The great Betrayal") with some languishing in cambridge archives (frost files box), and have been persecuted by the pakgov, much like how ch rehmat alis belongings were confiscated and he was exiled from pak and died alone and homeless in cambridge with even his grave funded by cambridge, but ive managed to acquire many physical copies of them and will make soft copies available soon

u/usavin — 11 days ago

[Title]

actually wait

So i was tweaking with hosting and managed to get a website running (java by YOURS TRULY) AND HOSTED IT ON THE DARKNET THRU TOR CUZ COOLPOINTS HELL YEAH. (and also cuz i cant afford a domain)

ps this isnt promotion or advertising cuz no one can join anw iys jst me and my friends but its so cool i thought id share

u/usavin — 12 days ago

So i was tweaking with hosting and managed to get a website running (java by YOURS TRULY) AND HOSTED IT ON THE DARKNET THRU TOR CUZ COOLPOINTS HELL YEAH. (and also cuz i cant afford a domain)

ps this isnt promotion or advertising cuz no one can join anw iys jst me and my friends but its so cool i thought id share

u/usavin — 12 days ago