What would you do in Cathy's shoes?
If you were Cathy and you just witnessed the man you loved get tortured and die along with the rest of your family, would you turn away Spike or take him with you? I would like to believe that I'd take Spike with me but obviously emotions would be running high since everyone I ever loved would have been slaughtered right in front of me, but regardless he's a fucking kid who was coerced into a psychotic cult...sure, Cathy didn't know this but the look on Spike's face tells all when he desperately pleads to come with..
What do y'all think?