u/justafnafdude

When did Charlie died? Where was the original Freddy's, what if I can answer those questions with only a couple paragraphs.

I present... Charlie82 and VintageToys.

What if the original Freddy's had the toy animatronics but it was in 1982 and Charlie died there and it would explain what BV saw he saw Charlie being killed and thrown in the alley, and when fnaf 2 takes place 1987 it had reopened with new technology not new animatronics.

This would explain the toy foxy in Elizabeths room, who cakebear is, and why nightmare bb is cannon but the others aren't. And this would mean that Charlie still died at Freddy's.

And with why he kills Charlie is he was humiliated by Henry due to him being the smarter one, the one who was better at making animatronics (at that time) and he was the one who people admired while afton sat in the shadows of freddys fame, and it didn't help that afton went to the bar he lived next to (JRS) he went to all the time to get drunk.

And thats my fnaf theory on when Charlie died and the original Freddy's.

I spent a ton of time on this and this feels like a major step in fnaf lore if its true and I hope people headcannon this and like it.