




Why do some beautiful paintings look like a collage?
When looking at other artists work, I often notice a weird visual effect. Even when the painting is beautiful, with perfect anatomy and high detail, the figures look like a magazine collage. It feels like they were cut out from somewhere else and pasted on top of a background.
I'd like to understand why this happens so I can avoid doing it in my paintings. I have a feeling it's a result of studio references or digital edition, but I don't understand how could this be fixed. Perhaps there's something in the ambiance that also needs to be applied to the figures or something like this.
What is happening in pieces like this that creates this "collage effect"? Is it an issue with edges, lighting, or atmosphere? I’d love to hear your thoughts so I can apply this knowledge to my own workflow
I love these artists, but I need to address the elephant in the room...
Images:
Song of the Angels by Bouguereau
Triumph of Daedalus Over Fate and Futility by Bryan Larsen.
Norman Rockwell titled Fifty-Fifty.
Homecoming by Norman Rockwell
Laura and the Dogs by Guillermo Lorca