u/coolkat2058

I’ve reached S5E10 of my rewatch and I’m always absolutely GUTTED by Jo and Ellen’s death scene. I’m literally crying for a number of reasons. 1. They didn’t have to kill them, like at all. They would’ve been great additions later in the show and I loved them as characters in general. I don’t think I’ll ever be able to forgive them for this. 2. The acting really makes you believe a mother is about to lose her daughter irl, absolutely heartbreaking. 3. Jo and Dean never got to get together in the…biblical sense. This is still a decision regarding the show that frustrates me. They could’ve been a great couple. SO much potential, smh.

Update: I did some research and learned that Jo was killed off because fans didn’t want Dean to have a love interest…wtf is up with that?? I’ve never heard of no shit like that before 😭 I’m gagged.

I’m currently rewatching S4E19 “Jump The Shark,” where Sam and Dean find out they have a brother, Adam. To be honest, this isn’t one of my favorites and i usually skip it or ignore it when I rewatch. However, something about it piqued my interest today and I’m curious to know who you think was right regarding Adam’s fate: Sam or Dean?

I feel like they both had a point, but leaned more towards Dean’s line of thinking. Let’s talk about Sam first. I think Sam was really struggling with anger, rage, vengefulness, and other strong feelings during this season because of his beef with Lilith. Plus, I think all the demon blood pumping through his veins made him more aggressive. It’s true that Adam would’ve benefited from learning how to protect himself and learning the truth about what was out there. However, I agree with Dean when he felt like Adam had a shot at a normal life. Dean always wanted better for Sam (like the father brother he was) and in turn, I could see him feeling the same way about Adam.

In addition to that, I do think both the boys were jealous of Adam, but for different reasons. I feel like Dean was jealous because it seemed like Adam had more of a normal connection with their father, and that hurt Dean due to how he was treated and how much responsibility was forced on him. On the other hand, I felt like Sam was also jealous of the normalcy, but because he didn’t get to finish school or have his girlfriend and friends, and I think that made him angry. Plus, there were many times throughout this season he called himself a “freak“ and I think he longed for the sense of normalcy that Adam had as a regular human.

Any who, just a thought! In the end, we all know what happened to Adam at the end of this episode.

I’m currently on S4E8 “Wishful Thinking” of my rewatch and I have a few thoughts. I actually love this episode and find it hilarious. It has some great moments like “Kneel before Todd!” Or Sam and Dean being “lollipop doctors” for the gigantic, depressed, stuffed bear. However, that dude “Wes” was an absolute creep. I’m not sure if I’m overreacting, but it feels like a case of SA. He made a wish that Hope would love him and when his wish came true, he absolutely engaged in intimate activities with her KNOWING it was because of a spell/magic. The poor girl didn’t even know who he was once he pulled the coin out of the wishing well.