u/Widgeet

Anarchist also enters in perhaps unsurprisingly at S tier

Rules:

• We're assessing on strength of the leaders not fun, pls tier list according to strength
• Will post daily
• Top upvoted comment wins and will ultimately place the leader in our follow up post tomorrow
• Please give an explanation for your vote
• Someone also made a good point to decide where in the tier a leader should be - leftmost is best, so if you're placing in an existing tier, let us know where you think they should be

Leader 14 - Shaper

Noble is one of our first tied votes with both an S and an A tier winning - ultimately I opted for A due to the S vote also mentioning A tier

Rules:

• We're assessing on strength of the leaders not fun, pls tier list according to strength
• Will post daily
• Top upvoted comment wins and will ultimately place the leader in our follow up post tomorrow
• Please give an explanation for your vote
• Someone also made a good point to decide where in the tier a leader should be - leftmost is best, so if you're placing in an existing tier, let us know where you think they should be

Leader 13 - Anarchist

Corsair is our first into D tier

Rules:

• We're assessing on strength of the leaders not fun, pls tier list according to strength
• Will post daily
• Top upvoted comment wins and will ultimately place the leader in our follow up post tomorrow
• Please give an explanation for your vote
• Someone also made a good point to decide where in the tier a leader should be - leftmost is best, so if you're placing in an existing tier, let us know where you think they should be

Leader 12 - Noble

In one of the more predictable votes, we see another S tier for the Overseer this time.

Rules:

• We're assessing on strength of the leaders not fun, pls tier list according to strength
• Will post daily
• Top upvoted comment wins and will ultimately place the leader in our follow up post tomorrow
• Please give an explanation for your vote
• Someone also made a good point to decide where in the tier a leader should be - leftmost is best, so if you're placing in an existing tier, let us know where you think they should be

Leader 11 - Corsair

A very fair and dominant S tier for the Archivist

Rules:

• We're assessing on strength of the leaders not fun, pls tier list according to strength
• Will post daily
• Top upvoted comment wins and will ultimately place the leader in our follow up post tomorrow
• Please give an explanation for your vote
• Someone also made a good point to decide where in the tier a leader should be - leftmost is best, so if you're placing in an existing tier, let us know where you think they should be

Leader 10 - Overseer

Demagogue enters in at C tier

Rules:

• We're assessing on strength of the leaders not fun, pls tier list according to strength
• Will post daily
• Top upvoted comment wins and will ultimately place the leader in our follow up post tomorrow
• Please give an explanation for your vote
• Someone also made a good point to decide where in the tier a leader should be - leftmost is best, so if you're placing in an existing tier, let us know where you think they should be

Leader 09 - Archivist

We somehow get our first S tier, the Feastbringer - definitely a huge shock for me and lots of variability in the voting, but somehow he makes it...

Rules:

• We're assessing on strength of the leaders not fun, pls tier list according to strength
• Will post daily
• Top upvoted comment wins and will ultimately place the leader in our follow up post tomorrow
• Please give an explanation for your vote
• Someone also made a good point to decide where in the tier a leader should be - leftmost is best, so if you're placing in an existing tier, let us know where you think they should be

Leader 08 - Demagogue

Warrior also enters C tier, behind the Rebel

Rules:

• We're assessing on strength of the leaders not fun, pls tier list according to strength
• Will post daily
• Top upvoted comment wins and will ultimately place the leader in our follow up post tomorrow
• Please give an explanation for your vote
• Someone also made a good point to decide where in the tier a leader should be - leftmost is best, so if you're placing in an existing tier, let us know where you think they should be

Leader 07 - Feastbringer

Rebel is our first entrant at C tier - definitely the most contested so far with lots of love but also lots of awareness that his downside is actually quite bad.

Rules:

• We're assessing on strength of the leaders not fun, pls tier list according to strength
• Will post daily
• Top upvoted comment wins and will ultimately place the leader in our follow up post tomorrow
• Please give an explanation for your vote
• Someone also made a good point to decide where in the tier a leader should be - leftmost is best, so if you're placing in an existing tier, let us know where you think they should be

Leader 06 - Warrior

Upstart enters at A tier joining the Elder. I ranked him above the Elder, given comments were also mentioning S tier

Rules:

• We're assessing on strength of the leaders not fun, pls tier list according to strength
• Will post daily
• Top upvoted comment wins and will ultimately place the leader in our follow up post tomorrow
• Please give an explanation for your vote
• Someone also made a good point to decide where in the tier a leader should be - leftmost is best, so if you're placing in an existing tier, let us know where you think they should be

Leader 05 - Rebel

Fuel Drinker also enters at B tier joining the Mystic

Rules:

• We're assessing on strength of the leaders not fun, pls tier list according to strength
• Will post daily
• Top upvoted comment wins and will ultimately place the leader in our follow up post tomorrow
• Please give an explanation for your vote

Leader 04 - Upstart

Mystic enters at B tier

Rules:

• We're assessing on strength of the leaders not fun, pls tier list according to strength
• Will post daily
• Top upvoted comment wins and will ultimately place the leader in our follow up post tomorrow
• Please give an explanation for your vote

Leader 03 - Fuel-Drinker

The Elder kicked us off and finished in A tier!

Rules:

• We're assessing on strength of the leaders not fun, pls tier list according to strength
• Will post daily if
• Top upvoted comment wins and will ultimately place the leader in our follow up post tomorrow
• Please give an explanation for your vote

Leader 02 - Mystic

Inspired by a similar post on r/rootgame - I thought it would be interesting to get the community's thoughts on the strength of the Arcs leaders in the base game!

Rules:

• We're assessing on strength of the leaders not fun, pls tier list according to strength
• Will post daily if ultimately we find this interesting and get engagement
• Top upvoted comment wins and will ultimately place the leader in our follow up post tomorrow
• Please give an explanation for your vote

Let's start with Leader 01 - Elder