
u/Upbeat_Dance_9014

a hypothetical 2016 tally hall album (and their first ever double album), which partially parallels the beatles white album.
spotify link: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/3yN9kSi1kdzNja9USxvOOJ
length: 94 minutes
disk 1:
isle unto thyself (hawley) [from miracle musical - hawaii part ii]
i’m gonna win (hawley-cantor) [from rob cantor - not a trampoline]
miss melody (horowitz) [from edu - sketches 3D]
bring her along (hawley) [from joe hawley - joe hawley joe hawley]
white ball (hawley) [from miracle musical - hawaii part ii]
lemons and pears (horiwitz) [from edu - sketches 3D]
garden of eden (cantor)[from rob cantor - not a trampoline]
black people white people (hawley) [from joe hawley - joe hawley joe hawley]
HEY YOU! (horowitz) [from edu - sketches 3D]
perfect (cantor) [from rob cantor - not a trampoline]
the apologue of hot rod duncan (hawley) [from joe hawley - joe hawley joe hawley]
fishes (horowitz) [from edu - MONSTERS]
time machine/moon waltz (cantor-hawley-karaca) [from miracle musical - hawaii part ii and cojum dip - cojum dip respectively]
disk 2:
daisy fingers (horowitz) [from edu - sketches 3D]
rotary park (hawley-sedghi) [from joe hawley - joe hawley joe hawley]
old bike (cantor) [from rob cantor - not a trampoline]
“the medley” (hawley-cantor)
- bahamian rap city [from joe hawley - joe hawley joe hawley]
- variations on a cloud [from miracle musical - hawaii part ii]
- welcome to tally hall (reprise) [unreleased but demoed tally hall song, uses original track from tally hall - marvin’s marvelous mechanical museum as placeholder]
just a friend (cover) [from tally hall - just a friend]
hummingbird (horowitz) [from edu - sketches 3D]
the mind electric (hawley) [from miracle musical - hawaii part ii]
the rainbow connection (cover) [from edu - sketches 3D]
aristole’s denial (hawley-karaca, hidden track) [from joe hawley - joe hawley joe hawley]
if you haven’t already, you should check these out
the beatles: huge inspiration for tally hall, along with just a great band in general
weezer: another huge influence on the tallies, check it out if you like stuff like greener and two wuv
they might be giants: similar “weird” vibe as tally hall, another early band to do internet stuff, and just a really fun band imo. they were tally hall/lemon demon before tally hall/lemon demon
miracle musical: literally just tally hall minus andrew. no, i’m not joking. if you like concept albums and if you like joe’s songs PLEASE check this out
the lemon twigs: underrated band with a similar beatley sound as some tally hall songs. they also have a new album coming out soon
lemon demon: i know, cliche recommendation, but you might like it. imagine they might be giants and tally hall combined (with more keyboards)