u/TinyTemperature9753

I’m building a trading simulator focused specifically on SMC/ICT concepts instead of generic paper trading.

The idea is to practice things like:

• Liquidity sweeps
• MSS/BOS
• FVGs
• Order blocks
• Balanced Price Ranges
• Killzones
• Session-based setups
• Replay trading with realistic price movement

Instead of just placing random buy/sell trades, the simulator would train pattern recognition and execution based on ICT-style models.

Some features I’m thinking about:

• Candle replay mode
• Custom scenarios/setups
• Trade journaling + statistics
• Difficulty levels
• Instant feedback on entries
• Backtesting-style learning
• Markup/drawing tools

I’m trying to figure out if traders would genuinely use something like this consistently, or if most people would still prefer TradingView replay + manual journaling.

What would make an app like this actually valuable to you?
And what features would instantly make you ignore it?

I’m building a trading simulator focused specifically on SMC/ICT concepts instead of generic paper trading.

The idea is to practice things like:

• Liquidity sweeps
• MSS/BOS
• FVGs
• Order blocks
• Balanced Price Ranges
• Killzones
• Session-based setups
• Replay trading with realistic price movement

Instead of just placing random buy/sell trades, the simulator would train pattern recognition and execution based on ICT-style models.

Some features I’m thinking about:

• Candle replay mode
• Custom scenarios/setups
• Trade journaling + statistics
• Difficulty levels
• Instant feedback on entries
• Backtesting-style learning
• Markup/drawing tools

I’m trying to figure out if traders would genuinely use something like this consistently, or if most people would still prefer TradingView replay + manual journaling.

What would make an app like this actually valuable to you?
And what features would instantly make you ignore it?

I’m building a trading simulator focused specifically on SMC/ICT concepts instead of generic paper trading.

The idea is to practice things like:

• Liquidity sweeps
• MSS/BOS
• FVGs
• Order blocks
• Balanced Price Ranges
• Killzones
• Session-based setups
• Replay trading with realistic price movement

Instead of just placing random buy/sell trades, the simulator would train pattern recognition and execution based on ICT-style models.

Some features I’m thinking about:

• Candle replay mode
• Custom scenarios/setups
• Trade journaling + statistics
• Difficulty levels
• Instant feedback on entries
• Backtesting-style learning
• Markup/drawing tools

I’m trying to figure out if traders would genuinely use something like this consistently, or if most people would still prefer TradingView replay + manual journaling.

What would make an app like this actually valuable to you?
And what features would instantly make you ignore it?

I’m building a trading simulator focused specifically on SMC/ICT concepts instead of generic paper trading.

The idea is to practice things like:

• Liquidity sweeps
• MSS/BOS
• FVGs
• Order blocks
• Balanced Price Ranges
• Killzones
• Session-based setups
• Replay trading with realistic price movement

Instead of just placing random buy/sell trades, the simulator would train pattern recognition and execution based on ICT-style models.

Some features I’m thinking about:

• Candle replay mode
• Custom scenarios/setups
• Trade journaling + statistics
• Difficulty levels
• Instant feedback on entries
• Backtesting-style learning
• Markup/drawing tools

I’m trying to figure out if traders would genuinely use something like this consistently, or if most people would still prefer TradingView replay + manual journaling.

What would make an app like this actually valuable to you?
And what features would instantly make you ignore it?