I'm trying real hard to not be exactly half of an eleven pound Black Forest ham...
I know it's a silly, fun, pretend time, so I'm not out for a pullitzer or anything, I just think it's fun when people notice inconsistencies or errors,and I wish I had the Commentary tracks to see what they say about some of the more obvious gaffs and whatnot.
That said, I was rewatching Tuesday the 17th again and two things kind of occurred to me. First, in the beginning if the episode they show Shawn's piñata in the lake and then Jason says they found it when they dredged the lake. Which creates the hilarious implication that Young Shawn didn't just toss Rick Astley into the water, but actually got chain and a decent-sized rock and, what, canoe-d out into the lake and Dexter-ed the thing? I can't help but imagine he made Coat Kid row. Second, after they find the dryer running and go looking for the killer/Annie, Gus goes off with Sissy. This isn't an error really, just something i think about. At this point, all the counselors know they are hired actors and Annie is okay, but they are acting like they are afraid because that's the job. Gus and Jason are the only two that know that Gus knows everything is still fake at this point, so why don't they show us him being A Player Named Gus, instead of him freaking out at a bird noise. They made a point of showing him wiping his hands on his pants, it could've been part of Shawn calling him out. At the very least, Shawn wasn't around him and Sissy in the woods, and I feel showing him freak out was kind of a weird choice.
If anyone is familiar with the Commentary on this one, feel free to weigh in.