



Best looking woman ever in a Western? I’ll go Claudia Cardinale in Once Upon a Time in the West
u/TXNOGG — 2 hours ago




John (obviously)
Bill and Javier - both reference sleeping with her in RDR1 and Arthur can antagonize Jack by saying “you don’t look like a Marston more like a Williamson or an Escuella!”
Dutch - “We all had her but he married her!”
Hosea - it seems like he was done with love/sex after Bessie died
Micah and Charles - joined the gang later when Abigail and John were already together
Arthur - This one is more complicated. In his diary he mentions wanting to marry her before she got with John. They also say he was still distraught and grieving after the death of Eliza and his son. Arthur also declines all Prostitutes in RDR2. Abigail seems to trust him and Hosea more than all the other male gang members.