Is my teacher right? They told me I’ll never be able to play Chopin’s Études or Scherzos.
I have been learning to play the piano for about 3 years. I started as an adult around 30yo. I am a diligent student, I practice a lot and I am always prepared for my lessons. I have full use of both hands.
Sometimes, when I ask my teacher when I will be able to play a certain piece (usually something more difficult, like Chopin’s Études, Scherzos, or Polonaises), they tell me that I will 'never in my life' be able to play them.
Is my teacher right? Is it true that even after many years of practice, I won't be able to play these pieces because they are so difficult?
It’s a bit depressing. Should I give up on my dreams of playing more advanced repertoire? Are they truly out of reach for a hobbyist without a formal musical education?
u/Remote-Pianist-pro — 22 hours ago