u/Ok_Performance_1090

I personally would say:

0. Dragon form Irene

1. August

2. Human Irene

3. Larcade (Someone once said they think God Serena's stronger because he's a "gildarts level mage" and Larcade "jobs to sting", but Larcade was still paralyzing 15+ people at a time, even Laxus, and Zeref, who had to tell Larcade to stop doing it because he was "also affecting his allies." Larcade also used holy magic, whereas Sting has a specific kind of magic that complements it, which is why he beat Larcade even though Laxus is way more powerful but couldn't beat Larcade. I love God Serena more as an all together character but Larcade is objectively more difficult to defeat. Larcade was paralyzing people so long he was even lecturing them as they were in place lmao)

4. Bloodman-So, some call bloodman the weakest or rate him less than Ajeel Ramal even because most of the attacks Bloodman used were not physical attacks, whereas Ajeel showed he does have incredible destructive power, but Bloodman is definitely not the weakest. Bloodman only used his powers more than fighting physically because there was practically no need for him to fight with fists because his powers were that deadly. Wall Eehto was already incredibly dangerous considering he did nearly kill Laxus who had to trick Wall into healing him, or else Wall may have killed him, but Wall also had to specifically target Laxus to contaminate him with the bane particles and Laxus didn't even die a full 2 minutes later, and Wall decided to use etherion (I love Wall but LMAO) whereas Bloodman could effortlessly make multiple drop dead from 30+ feet away just from walking nearby them and they would die instantly. One also could say that Laxus didn't immediately die because he's super strong, whereas a regular civilian with no powers would die sooner, but Tempester only turned into a bunch of bane particles when his body dissolved when he died, whereas Bloodman can effortlessly contaminate 100+ people with bane particles while he is alive. The bane particles of it may be only one aspect of it, but one also could say that, in Bloodman's first time alive, considering Gajeel wasn't as strong as Laxus, but Gajeel specifically fought Bloodman because his lungs were made of iron, and Gajeel was the only person Bloodman directly fought, it could imply that his bane particles are that lethal that even Laxus would die just from being in close enough range to him. Also, he did lose to Rogue in his 2nd time alive but that was because he was way weaker than before, clearly lost at least 70% of his power, whereas in his first time alive specifically only someone with iron lungs could fight him, and even Gajeel had to absorb Bloodman's power and use it against hin to beat him, but he still was strong enough that he knocked Rogue off his feet, so in his first time alive he definitely was capable of using physical force as well but just opted not to. So if the bane particles were to scale up to his full strength, one could say he's easily the most dangerous of the spriggan 12 beside Irene/August. He may even be physically stronger than August but August just being considered the strongest in terms of magical power/how hard he is to defeat. Bloodman also is so strong that even when he could tell he was damaged enough that he would die, he pulled Gajeel who is already incredibly tough into the portal and Gajeel couldn't escape his grip even though he wanted to. Bloodman's "ice demon rage" also was evenly matched with Gajeel's iron dragon roar, and by the alvarez arc Gajeel had to have been stronger than ajeel. Gajeel just didn't fight him because he got sick as soon as he got on the ship, as he is a dragon slayer. Bloodman is just awesome. One also could infer that he's stronger than a god

5. Wall Eehto (He would develop immunity to Dimaria's time spell. Ultear was able to break it, so that implies that Dimaria's spell contained a certain weakness. Laxus also beat him because blood has mercury which combined with lightning has an explosive effect. The etherion is also a continental level attack)

6. God Serena

7. Dimaria

8. Invel

9. Ajeel-Natsu did land a solid punch on him but he also unveiled a massive sandstorm that Laxus had to decimate for it to not kill both Natsu, Lucy, Doranbolt, Wendy, Gray and even giant form Makarov

10. Jacob (People frequently rate Jacob last but he's noticeably more powerful than neinhart. Neinhart, even after receiving the power boost and was boasting about "bursting at the seams with power" got knocked out by Natsu before he could even do anything to Natsu like summon a guy to fight him, even though Brandish said her "magic can't touch him", whereas Jacob was difficult for both Natsu and Lucy to defeat. So if Natsu without the END form were to hypothetically be a 13th member of the spriggan 12 he'd be rated 11; It's considerable given that Jacob both could teleport and still was super strong for the average person. He also could still paralyze and torture one person at a time like Mavis for instance)

11. Neinhart

12. Brandish (I adore Brandish but she can only use her techniques for so long. She did also get distracted by Ajeel's sandstorm and was knocked out in one punch by Cana)