u/Nirathaim

I've just done a deep dive into Chthonic beings from Mage's Summoners, to Geist 2e's treatment, and found them lacking.

I'm not sure why I dislike them so much, and feel they need a rewrite (especially the 1e stuff). But I know what I like when I see it (like Hosts from WtF).

So what are your favourite CofD antagonists and why?

Or what kind of antagonists would you like to see? Something from Exalted or WoD? Yozis, KotE?

How do you feel about the Underworld in CofD in general and as a space to create plothooks for your games? And what would make it more interesting?

What mechanical issues were there in 1st Ed Geist? (I have heard this repeated several times, but I don't know what it was in reference to).

And were these issues addressed in 2nd edition?