u/New-Sheepherder-1373

Image 1 — Morality Scale Tournament but the question changes daily: Commenter Selection Villain Edition: Day 1 - "Make some friends!"
Image 2 — Morality Scale Tournament but the question changes daily: Commenter Selection Villain Edition: Day 1 - "Make some friends!"
Image 3 — Morality Scale Tournament but the question changes daily: Commenter Selection Villain Edition: Day 1 - "Make some friends!"
Image 4 — Morality Scale Tournament but the question changes daily: Commenter Selection Villain Edition: Day 1 - "Make some friends!"

Morality Scale Tournament but the question changes daily: Commenter Selection Villain Edition: Day 1 - "Make some friends!"

We have all our votes in, so please welcome our...twenty contestants

Yep, as an added little bonus twist, I decided to add the top 6 of the previous comment section instead of just the top 2, so our full cast is now:

Bojack Horseman ("")

Caine ("The Amazing Digital Circus")

Claude Frollo ("Hunchback of Notre Dame")

Cyn ("Murder Drones")

Dahlia Hawthorne ("Ace Attorney")

Dimentio ("Super Paper Mario")

Esdeath ("Akame Ga Kill!")

GLaDOS ("Portal")

Handsome Jack ("Borderlands")

Jimmy ("MouthWashing")

Junko Enoshima ("Danganronpa")

Kyubey ("Puella Magi")

Makima ("Chainsaw Man"

Montgomery Burns ("The Simpsons")

Qu Drone #187452988331 ("All Tomorrows") - they will be representing the Qu as a whole

Ridley ("Metroid")

Soundwave ("Transformers IDW Comics")

Spooky ("Spooky's Jumpscare Mansion")

Walter White ("Breaking Bad")

Yatsu ("Tetsuo Trilogy")

The first contest: Who can end up making the most friends in three days

Please do make sure to check out all pages to see the stipulations for the game (alongside a map of where the contestants will be staying for the duration of the game)

u/New-Sheepherder-1373 — 13 hours ago

How would you morally rank Angel Gabriel (Angel Hare) - Explanation (+Spoilers) in description

Angel Gabriel is a guardian angel type character who communicates through live connection, usually through TV broadcast or, in another case, online stream

They serve as a protective figure and caretaker to those who watch her, as shown by her relationship with Jonah, including protection from their abusive father at the time

This even extended to when she was properly introduced herself to the internet and she stretched herself thin, almost to the point of being completely invisible, to watch over as many people as she could

On the other hand...

She murdered Jonah's adoptive father, with methods still unknown and managed to cause a biblical flood toward a records room to erase the incident entirely. She did it for the sake of protecting Jonah of course, but the fact still stands

She also ordered Jonah to go to a friends house for the sake of creating an alibi and also make sure he didn't have to lie

and with how many people she could have reached out too, especially with the invention of the interntet, its unclear how many cases such as this have occurred

This also incidentally created a rift between Jonah's friend, Segen and their guardian angel in the proces

u/New-Sheepherder-1373 — 4 days ago

Morality Scale Tournament but the question changes daily: Commenter Selection Villain - Selection 4: Terrible Web Characters

Bojack Horseman and Heisneberg have been selected for the torunament

Pick two characters from a web show or comic to add to the tournament

There were no characters who originated there in the original tournament but, for the sake of the game (and story) Pax Malum will not be particpating

After all, if you ask me, I consider myself a very moral and upstanding citizen!

u/New-Sheepherder-1373 — 4 days ago

Morality Scale Tournament but the question changes daily: Commenter Selection Villain - Selection 3: Monstrous Movie Characters

Ridley and Handsome Jack have been picked for the tournament

Pick two movie villains you think would be interesting for this new round

note: Art the Clown, Freddy Kreuger, Pennywise and the Joker are disqualified due to participating in the previous tournament

u/New-Sheepherder-1373 — 6 days ago

Hello everyone;...its been a while, huh?

Gonna go upfront and say 2026 has not been a good year for me. Personal issues, mixed with stress from work, mixed with a lot of scope creep for the reformed villain one led to me just having...almost no motivation for it, especially with my ideas proving wayyyy too ambitious for what it is.

Is it cancelled? I hate setting that sort of thing in stone, but don't count on me finishing it soon. I think its officially been so long that returning to it would just be awkward.

With that said, there was one more idea I wanted to do for a bit. Make another villain based one, but have the commenters decide who gets added, so that's what I'm doing

I only filled in two here. That being, two villains who I originally had on the first villain list that half a year or so ago, but ultimately scrapped

GLaDOS from Portal (who I eventually replaced in favor of Slappy)

and Kyubey from Madoka Magika (who I eventually replaced in favor of Springtrap)

the rest of the categories are up to you

in this case, we are starting with "returning champions"

in this case, you may pick one of the original characters here (excluding the original "winner" deemed most evil, Freddy Kreuger) to join. Top 2 comments get added

I listed them on screen, but as a recap, your choices are

AM (I Have No Mouth and I Must Scream)

Art the Clown (Terrifier)

Bill Cipher (Gravity Falls)

Eric Cartman (South Park)

Homelander (The Boys)

Joker (DC)

Holden (Blood Meridian)

Junko Enoshima (Danganronpa)

Kefka (Final Fantasy)

The Lich (adventure Time)

Pennywise (IT)

Manfred Von Karma (Ace Attorney)

Mr Burns (The Simpsons)

Slappy the Dummy (Goosebumps)

Springtrap (FNAF)

Do note, any character who has previously competed will not be allowed to join in any future ones (example: if Springtrap doesn't get picked here, he can't be chosen for the video game villain later down the line)

Once we do have a full lineup, we'll start up this new version of the game.

Note, you don't have to pick the most evil of the lineup, as you do, who you think would be the most interesting for this sort of game, and who'd create the most fun debate (or just pick your favorite here)

Good to be back, hope we can make this season a good one everyone!

u/New-Sheepherder-1373 — 7 days ago