I thought Dollarama food was cheaper, but that’s only true some of the time.
Erin compared 88 food items at Dollarama against Walmart, No Frills, and Food Basics. Only 36 out of 88 items were actually cheaper at Dollarama, which works out to 40.91%. Even if you include the three items that tied in price, that only rises to 44.32%.
And it's mostly to do with package size.
Dollarama often sells smaller versions of brand-name items, so the sticker price looks cheap, but the price per 100g or 100ml can be worse than grocery stores. For example, Honey Nut Cheerios were 272g at Dollarama compared with 430g at Walmart/Food Basics, and Kraft Cheese Whiz was 250g at Dollarama versus 450g elsewhere.
Some of the best Dollarama deals were tomato paste, Campbell’s Cream of Mushroom soup, strawberry jam, Quaker Harvest Crunch, Joe Louis, sardines, pickles, Starburst, table salt, and Viva Puffs.
Some of the worst buys were peppercorns, mayo, soy sauce, peanut butter, mustard, ketchup, granola bars, pudding cups, Jell-O, and Worcestershire sauce.
Dollarama still can be great for certain pantry items, small households, or when you only need a little bit. But if you’re feeding a family or already going to a grocery store, the better deal is often Walmart, No Frills, or Food Basics, especially when sales and store brands are involved.