




The big problem with these Diary of a Wimpy Kid fanfictions. (And most fanfics in general)
You know I always hear people talking about on here how much the modern books have fallen off compared to the original, and yeah I agree. Jeff Kinney clearly caters to younger kids now instead of being more all ages themed like the older books (I'll talk about the official books another time) but I always found it ironic that a lot of the people in this community talk so badly about modern diary of a wimpy kid books while glossing over the absolute swill that's posted here at times. The thing about Modern Diary of a wimpy kid is despite it's flaws, it still feels like the source material. These most of the time have none of that. I can go on. The terrible mischaracterization to fuel their narrative. (Usually for a romance plot or whatever) Edgy humor that's nothing like the humor in the books for the sake of shock value and the funny. Along with the really horrible grammar in most of these because this subreddit is mostly little kids. Another thing i don't like is that a lot of people use an artstyle for their fanfictions that isn't even a adjacent to Diary of a wimpy kid. I mean if you looked at the cover you wouldn't even be able to tell it's Diary of a wimpy kid, and it just makes it feel disconnected from what's it's trying to be. Though the worst thing is when they try to make Diary of a wimpy kid fucking scary. I mean I already am not a fan of the ironic horror, mainly due to the fact I find it overly edgy and cringey shock value. But whenever it's unironic, it's so much worse. Diary of a wimpy kid shouldn't be horror, and most the times I've seen horror related to it. It's just awful. But yeah I'd say a lot of the stuff posted here is way worse than what Jeff Kinney pushes out these days, and I mean by a long shot. And to those people who say "let them do what they want" I'm not stopping anyone, just giving an honest opinion. People should know how to write properly and faithfully to the source material when making a fanfiction. If it was me doing all the bad writing, I'd just make an original project instead of making a fanfiction that ultimately feels completely out of line with the originals. So I have a little assignment to the people here. Please study your source material better before making a huge fan project.