u/MatooMan

Tone, Timbre And Tuning Tips

One of the beautiful things about piobaireachd is that it's all about the interplay between the chanter and the drones. It's the music that the instrument evolved to play.

The sound of the bagpipe is of paramount importance to the performance of piobaireachd - as a result it's a good idea to know how to get the best sound possible.

Some prefer darker tones produced by some pipe chanters, others favour particular brands of drone reeds for an enriching hum or a warm buzz. There are even people who try to play at frequencies like 466Hz (Bb) or 440Hz (concert A), believing it's closest to what would have been played 'back then'.

Tell us some of your tips and tricks here!

reddit.com
u/MatooMan — 4 days ago

Favourite Little Pibrochs

Have you got a favourite wee tune? Something that is musical and pleasing to the ear, but unlikely to win any competitive gongs?

Inspired by the piece here:

https://bagpipe.news/2020/08/06/tunes-and-competition-piobaireachd/

And the set tunes pairs from 2010:

The Piobaireachd Society recommends the following arrangements for competitions in 2010:

A. SENIOR COMPETITION

The following pairs of tunes are recommended:

1 The Sisters Lament and PS 4 p109, K p41

	Nameless (Angus Mackays MS)	PS 4 p111, K p42

2 The Battle of Glenshiel and PS 4 p124

	A Glase	PS 11 p320

3 Duncan MacRae of Kintails Lament and PS 4 p121, K p40

	Nameless (Colin Campbells Canntaireachd MS)	PS 4 p124, K p43

4 The Old Womans Lullaby and PS 4 p113, K p39

	The Aged Warriors Sorrow	PS 12 p360

5 Lament for Red Hector of the Battles and PS 4 p111, K p42

	The Middling Spree	PS 11 p322

6 The Park Piobaireachd No.1 and PS 4 p113, K p46

	The Pretty Dirk	PS 11 p318

7 Nameless Lament (MacArthur MS) and PS 13 p420 or 421 but not p423

	Lament for the Bishop of Argyll	PS 15 p509

8 Salute on the Birth of Rory Mor MacLeod and PS 4 p121, K p38

	Left Hand	PS 14 p489
u/MatooMan — 6 days ago

"Ed Neigh was a world-class performer, adjudicator and above all teacher of highland bagpipe music.  The mission of this website is to share the vast amount of instructional materials and recordings that Ed produced during his lifetime. His series of instructional piobaireachd recordings will be of particular interest to students of the classical music of the highland bagpipe as they are unlike any other instructional materials in existence for this style."

Accessible here:

https://edneighpiob.org/list-of-tunes

reddit.com
u/MatooMan — 7 days ago

"A retrospective of the Pibroc'h or Piobaireachd competition (Uist and Barra Piobaireachd's contest) held on March 24, 1991, in Glasgow. The islands of Uist and Barra belong to the Hebrides archipelago in northwest Scotland. Robert Wallace received first prize. The sound quality is rather poor, but the quality of the performances is noteworthy. Excerpts from the various pieces presented:

Robert Wallace "The Unjust Incarceration" (DS, DD 0:00)

Roddy MacLeod "Tulloch Ard" (V1 Thumb, V2 L1 and L2 1:01)

Robert Wallace "The Unjust Incarceration" (DS End L1, L2 and L3, DD L1 and L2 4:05)

Colin Drummond "Lament for Mary MacLeod" (V1 L2 and L3, V1 D L1 and L2 6:35)

Andrew Wright "Earl of Seaforth's Salute" (V1D L3, TS L1 and L2 8:42)

Willie MacCallum "Roderick MacLoude's Lament" (CD, Urlar L1 10:37)

James Bayne "Old Men of the Shells No. 1" (V1S L2 and L3, V1 D, TS L1) 12:58)

Ronald MacShannon "Lament for MacSwan of Roaig" (V1 L2 and L3, V1D L1 and L2 18:04)

Allan MacDonald "The Unjust Incarceration" (Urlar L3, DS and DD 18:04)

Robert Wallace "The Unjust Incarceration" (DD, T, C L1 and L2 21:06)

Presentation of the 1st prize to Robert Wallace and continuation of his pibroch.

BBC Scotland broadcast.

Uploaded to YouTube by youennpiper"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8x-LvIo9eaI

u/MatooMan — 11 days ago
▲ 3 r/CeolMorClub+1 crossposts

I have the ground of this piece on sheet music though don't know the variations or the name.

u/MatooMan — 11 days ago

So while there a couple of formal versions of canntaireachd that have survived to the modern day - MacCrimmon and Nether Lorn being two - many pipers sing their own made up sounds rather than a formal system.

My question is:

  1. Do you sing at all when teaching or learning?
  2. Is it a consistent, formal system - or one of your own invention?
reddit.com
u/MatooMan — 13 days ago

Has anyone got any favourites when it comes to modern piobaireachd? Or has anyone ever composed their own?

John MacLellan has a book of ceol mor out, so does Donald MacLeod. Other names like Bruce Gandy, Stuart Samson and Hugh MacCallum have all written some and there are a few modern books like the 20th Century Collection, Glenfiddich Ceol Mor, and the Shasta Collection.

Is it something you've ever tangled with?

Here's a little guide on how you could compose your own pieces:

https://www.piobaireachd.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/Methods-of-Piobaireachd-Composition-by-John-Dew-Slides-without-musical-examples.pdf

reddit.com
u/MatooMan — 15 days ago

Just a chance to share any general websites or pages of interest for piobaireachd. Post your own below that have helped you or could be useful for others.

===

Robert Wallace's pages on piobaireachd:
https://pipingpress.com/piobaireachd-2/

This includes reviews, lists of gold medallists, thought pieces and more. His website also has recordings for sale and offers tutor books too.

===

Wikipedia's definition and history on pibroch:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pibroch

This is wider ranging than you might think. Speaks to the harp tradition, modern performance and origins.

===

The old 'alt pibroch club' content, folded into Barnaby Brown's site:
https://pibroch.net/

This includes all primary source manuscripts, discussion on
points of playing, and even a copy of the first five PS books before they started the series again.

===

Archives @ NPC:
https://archives.thepipingcentre.co.uk/

This features old back issues of the piping times, international piper, piping today and others, as well as an oral history - noting the tradition.

===

Piper's Persuasion:
https://www.piperspersuasion.com/

This features interviews with many names in piping, all available for free - products, prizes, styles, and so much more on offer in these discussions.

reddit.com
u/MatooMan — 17 days ago

Hello

I've started a wee pibroch subreddit - would be happy to see any posts, topics, questions, discussions or comments added there:

https://www.reddit.com/r/CeolMorClub/

I'm planning on adding more resources, including a tune of the month there soon, and am looking for mods to help make it the place to discuss ceol mor online.

There's a thread I'd love everyone to contribute to here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/CeolMorClub/comments/1sr7yt3/performance_and_interpretation_tips_tricks/

And another one here where you can introduce yourself:

https://www.reddit.com/r/CeolMorClub/comments/1spogr6/welcome_to_rceolmorclub_introduce_yourself_and/

See you there

reddit.com
u/MatooMan — 18 days ago