"Post-punk" - is it a genre? Is this label too broad to be useful?
8 hours ago the Generator assigned me Juju (1981) by Siouxsie and the Banshees - I'm happy to call it post-punk. (I wouldn't have called it that at the time - I knew it had moved on from The Scream, I think I would have called it new wave.) I enjoyed listening to it (again) very much and was ready to listen to another album.
So I decided to have another try at an album from 1001 MORE that put me off when I first started listening to it - viagr aboys (2025) by Viagra Boys. This time I enjoyed it, but what to call it? Apparently they are post-punk as well? If there is another label for bands that have declaiming vocalists with 'interesting' ideas - it could fit in Pere Ubu as well? But I wouldn't call Viagra Boys art rock - there is grunge and appetite for riffs.
Anyway I am curious if others would also call Juju and viagr aboys post-punk, or what - and what do you think of the idea that there is a genre called post-punk, such that you can say (from the sound not just history) that a song or album is or isn't post-punk?