u/LauraW1215

I'm looking into two different itineraries:

• Cozumel, Mexico
• George Town, Grand Cayman
• Falmouth, Jamaica
• Disney Castaway Cay

Or:

• Tortola, British Virgin Islands
• San Juan, Puerto Rico
• Disney Castaway Cay

The problem is, I got spoiled and visited both Castaway Cay and Lookout Cay on my first disney cruise last month and now I am not sure what non-private island ports have to offer. After the cost of the cruise i'm not going to want to pay 100's on port excursions. I just want nice beaches to hang out at a bit before getting back on the ship. I would love if these also went to lookout cay, but they don't. Which itinerary would be best for easier beach-going and free activities?