u/Kaipirinhas

First time home buyer...need help understanding my numbers.

I’m looking for a sanity check on a potential home purchase in San Francisco. I’m transitioning into a white collar job and want to see if these numbers are as sustainable as they look on paper. I grew up in section 8 housing/apartments and never lived in a home so home ownership is very new to me.

Bio:

  • 35y/o, frugal mindset, no debt.
  • GF will be earning 165K but I dont feel right charging her rent and profiting off of her.
  • Still trying to figure what neighborhoods to buy. Can get more bang for my buck in Berkeley/Oakland but will feel like I'll be missing out on "SF"
  • Want to buy because moved every 2 years since I graduated college and want an "anchor." I know this is an emotional argument but I will feel very transient in renting.
  • I could save more by renting but I do I just dump that into my brokerage?
  • Concerned about buying at the top of market too...

Financials:

  • Income (W2): $175,000 base. (but possible bonus_
  • VAD: ~$5,100/mo, tracks inflation.
  • Total Monthly Inflow (Net): ~$15,200 (Post-tax)
  • Assets: $1.2M (Mix of brokerage, 401k, and HYSA). Current ROI is roughly 4% (know I need to diversify better).

Target Property:

  • Price: up to $1.5M (San Francisco/Oakland).
  • Loan: VA Jumbo Loan (0% down, waived funding fee).
  • Rate: Approved for 5.5%.

Projected Monthly:

  • PITA - Total Housing: ~$11,267.

Strategy:

  1. Tax Arbitrage: Between the $40k SALT cap and the mortgage interest deduction, I expect my federal tax liability on the $175k salary to be minimal. I plan to adjust my W-4 to increase monthly cash flow.
  2. Retirement: I still plan to max 401k ($24.5k) and maybe Backdoor Roth ($7.5k).
  3. Cash Flow: After the house and retirement, I’m looking at roughly $3,000–$3,400/mo for "everything else" (food, lifestyle, travel).

My Questions:

  1. Is a ~75% housing-to-net-income ratio insane given that I have a $1.2M safety net?
  2. With $1.2M in assets, should I put a down payment to lower the monthly P&I, or keep the liquidity in the market (aiming for better than 4%)?
  3. Are there any SF-specific "gotchas" I’m missing for a 2026 purchase?
  4. How much above 1.5M can I stretch?

reddit.com
u/Kaipirinhas — 3 hours ago

New middle class/first home purchase ever, do my numbers make sense?

I’m looking for a sanity check on a potential home purchase in San Francisco. I’m transitioning into a white collar job and want to see if these numbers are as sustainable as they look on paper. I grew up in section 8 housing/apartments and never lived in a home so home ownership is very new to me.

Bio:

  • 35y/o, frugal mindset, no debt.
  • GF will be earning 165K but I dont feel right charging her rent and profiting off of her.
  • Still trying to figure what neighborhoods to buy. Can get more bang for my buck in Berkeley/Oakland but will feel like I'll be missing out on "SF"
  • Want to buy because moved every 2 years since I graduated college and want an "anchor." I know this is an emotional argument but I will feel very transient in renting.
  • I could save more by renting but I do I just dump that into my brokerage?
  • Concerned about buying at the top of market too...

Financials:

  • Income (W2): $175,000 base. (but possible bonus_
  • Non-Taxable/Fixed Income: ~$5,100/mo, tracks inflation.
  • Total Monthly Inflow (Net): ~$15,200 (Post-tax)
  • Assets: $1.2M (Mix of brokerage, 401k, and HYSA). Current ROI is roughly 4% (know I need to diversify better).

Target Property:

  • Price: up to $1.5M (San Francisco/Oakland).
  • Loan: VA Jumbo Loan (0% down, waived funding fee).
  • Rate: Approved for 5.5%.

Projected Monthly:

  • PITA - Total Housing: ~$11,267.

Strategy:

  1. Tax Arbitrage: Between the $40k SALT cap and the mortgage interest deduction, I expect my federal tax liability on the $175k salary to be minimal. I plan to adjust my W-4 to increase monthly cash flow.
  2. Retirement: I still plan to max 401k ($24.5k) and maybe Backdoor Roth ($7.5k).
  3. Cash Flow: After the house and retirement, I’m looking at roughly $3,000–$3,400/mo for "everything else" (food, lifestyle, travel).

My Questions:

  1. Is a ~75% housing-to-net-income ratio insane given that I have a $1.2M safety net?
  2. With $1.2M in assets, should I put a down payment to lower the monthly P&I, or keep the liquidity in the market (aiming for better than 4%)?
  3. Are there any SF-specific "gotchas" I’m missing for a 2026 purchase?
  4. How much above 1.5M can I stretch?

reddit.com
u/Kaipirinhas — 4 hours ago

First home purchase ever, do my numbers make sense?

I’m looking for a sanity check on a potential home purchase in San Francisco. I’m transitioning into a white collar job and want to see if these numbers are as sustainable as they look on paper. I grew up in section 8 housing/apartments and never lived in a home so home ownership is very new to me.

Bio:

  • 35y/o, frugal mindset, no debt.
  • GF will be earning 165K but I dont feel right charging her rent and profiting off of her.
  • Still trying to figure what neighborhoods to buy. Can get more bang for my buck in Berkeley/Oakland but will feel like I'll be missing out on "SF"
  • Want to buy because moved every 2 years since I graduated college and want an "anchor." I know this is an emotional argument but I will feel very transient in renting.
  • I could save more by renting but I do I just dump that into my brokerage?
  • Concerned about buying at the top of market too...

Financials:

  • Income (W2): $175,000 base. (but possible bonus_
  • Non-Taxable/Fixed Income: ~$5,100/mo, tracks inflation.
  • Total Monthly Inflow (Net): ~$15,200 (Post-tax)
  • Assets: $1.2M (Mix of brokerage, 401k, and HYSA). Current ROI is roughly 4% (know I need to diversify better).

Target Property:

  • Price: up to $1.5M (San Francisco/Oakland).
  • Loan: VA Jumbo Loan (0% down, waived funding fee).
  • Rate: Approved for 5.5%.

Projected Monthly:

  • PITA - Total Housing: ~$11,267.

Strategy:

  1. Tax Arbitrage: Between the $40k SALT cap and the mortgage interest deduction, I expect my federal tax liability on the $175k salary to be minimal. I plan to adjust my W-4 to increase monthly cash flow.
  2. Retirement: I still plan to max 401k ($24.5k) and maybe Backdoor Roth ($7.5k).
  3. Cash Flow: After the house and retirement, I’m looking at roughly $3,000–$3,400/mo for "everything else" (food, lifestyle, travel).

My Questions:

  1. Is a ~75% housing-to-net-income ratio insane given that I have a $1.2M safety net?
  2. With $1.2M in assets, should I put a down payment to lower the monthly P&I, or keep the liquidity in the market (aiming for better than 4%)?
  3. Are there any SF-specific "gotchas" I’m missing for a 2026 purchase?
  4. How much can I stretch above 1.5M?

reddit.com
u/Kaipirinhas — 4 hours ago

First home purchase ever, do my numbers make sense?

I’m looking for a sanity check on a potential home purchase in San Francisco. I’m transitioning into a white collar job and want to see if these numbers are as sustainable as they look on paper. I grew up in section 8 housing/apartments and never lived in a home so home ownership is very new to me.

Bio:

  • 35y/o, frugal mindset, no debt.
  • GF will be earning 165K but I dont feel right charging her rent and profiting off of her.
  • Still trying to figure what neighborhoods to buy. Can get more bang for my buck in Berkeley/Oakland but will feel like I'll be missing out on "SF"
  • Want to buy because moved every 2 years since I graduated college and want an "anchor." I know this is an emotional argument but I will feel very transient in renting.
  • I could save more by renting but I do I just dump that into my brokerage?
  • Concerned about buying at the top of market too...

Financials:

  • Income (W2): $175,000 base. (but possible bonus_
  • Non-Taxable/Fixed Income: ~$5,100/mo, tracks inflation.
  • Total Monthly Inflow (Net): ~$15,200 (Post-tax)
  • Assets: $1.2M (Mix of brokerage, 401k, and HYSA). Current ROI is roughly 4% (know I need to diversify better).

Target Property:

  • Price: up to $1.5M (San Francisco/Oakland).
  • Loan: VA Jumbo Loan (0% down, waived funding fee).
  • Rate: Approved for 5.5%.

Projected Monthly:

  • PITA/Maintenance - Total Housing: ~$11,267.

Strategy:

  1. Tax Arbitrage: Between the $40k SALT cap and the mortgage interest deduction, I expect my federal tax liability on the $175k salary to be minimal. I plan to adjust my W-4 to increase monthly cash flow.
  2. Retirement: I still plan to max 401k ($24.5k) and maybe Backdoor Roth ($7.5k).
  3. Cash Flow: After the house and retirement, I’m looking at roughly $3,000–$3,400/mo for "everything else" (food, lifestyle, travel).

My Questions:

  1. Is a ~75% housing-to-net-income ratio insane given that I have a $1.2M safety net?
  2. With $1.2M in assets, should I put a down payment to lower the monthly P&I, or keep the liquidity in the market (aiming for better than 4%)?
  3. Are there any SF-specific "gotchas" I’m missing for a 2026 purchase?
  4. How far above the 1.5M can I go?

reddit.com
u/Kaipirinhas — 4 hours ago
▲ 17 r/BayAreaRealEstate+2 crossposts

Another where should I live post. So far this is what has been recommended by freinds.

Moving end of June and and haven't even started looking.

It will be my partner, me (myself?) and a cat. We are mid 30's. We will have at least one car. She works in Berkeley (M-F) and I will be WFH/downtown office.

Anywhere else you'd recommend?

Friends* goddamit

So far considering: North Beach Pacific Heights Rincon Hill SoMa Mission Bay Potrero Hill Mission Noe Valley Glen Park Outer Richmond Excelsior Crocker Amazon

u/Kaipirinhas — 1 day ago