
u/Important-Self-1179

In 1981, self-declared prophet Suzan Barnes Carson and her husband Michael Bear Carson murdered 3 people across California Suzan identified as witches, including a hitchhiker shot twice in the head after his leg touched hers in the truck cab.
On January 23, 1999, 2-year-old Tacoma, Washington girl Teekah Lewis vanished from a bowling alley arcade while her mother stood feet away. She has never been found.
Teekah was a Black and Native American girl, approximately 3 feet tall and 35 pounds, with black hair, brown eyes, and pierced ears. She was wearing a green Tweety Bird sweatshirt, white sweatpants, and red, white, and black Air Jordan shoes. Her sisters described her as a “mature” toddler who never left her mother’s side. She slept with her mother every night. source
In 1986, Darla Harper’s 2-year-old daughter told police men in masks “put Mommy in a bag.” Police found a lime-soaked tarp and a bone in her ex-husband’s crawlspace. He died in 2013 without ever being charged. Darla has never been found.
Darla was 25, an IRS analyst in Little Rock known for never missing a shift without calling ahead. Her 2-year-old daughter Leslie was found alone in the apartment the next morning. Ex-husband Barry Harper spent the following week with bandaged hands remodeling his bathroom. He was never charged. source
In 1983, Michael and Suzan Carson confessed to murdering 3 people they called witches, claiming Suzan was a prophet of God and Michael her divine executioner. A leg touching a stranger’s leg was enough to sentence him to death. They demanded a live TV confession, then pleaded not guilty.
In January 2026, Jonathan Gerlach was caught leaving a Philadelphia cemetery with a burlap sack containing mummified children and skulls. Police found 100+ stolen human remains in his home, some 200 years old. He had been selling them on Facebook. In Pennsylvania, this was completely legal.
Flight paramedic Joshua Hunsucker poisoned his wife Stacy, 32, with eye drops for 5 years, then called 911. He had told coworkers beforehand: "If I ever wanted to kill someone, I'd use Visine." He collected $250,000 in life insurance, bought a boat, and moved in his girlfriend.
In March 1976, 15-year-old Stephanie Sempell disappeared in Florida. Her family believed they reported her missing no report was ever filed. Her remains were found 9 months later and sat unidentified for 28 years. Her killer has never been found.
Stephanie Sempell, 15, left Boca Raton in March 1976 for Key West with an unidentified male companion. Her bones were found nine months later with a knotted T-shirt containing her hair tangled inside the knot. source
In 1977, Terri Jentz, 19, and Avra Goldman, 20, were camping at Cline Falls State Park, Oregon when a man drove his truck over their tent and axed them. The town named a suspect. His hatchet was missing. He failed two lie detector tests. He was never arrested. Who was he?
Both women survived, though their injuries were severe. Terri Jentz spent nearly two decades investigating the attack herself, identifying a local man named Dirk Duran whom townspeople had suspected from the start.
His hatchet was never found. Duran failed two polygraph tests but was never charged. Jentz published her investigation in the 2006 book Strange Piece of Paradise. Dirk Duran died in 2010. The case remains officially unsolved. source
On December 12, 1990, 31-year-old Norine Higuchi Brown left her Long Island home at 11 p.m. to buy ingredients for Christmas cookies. The next day was her 32nd birthday. Her car was found in the supermarket parking lot with wrapped gifts and $45 inside. She has never been found.
That afternoon, Norine had taken her children to have their photo taken with Santa Claus. The Pathmark Supermarket was less than a mile from her home. When her car was discovered the next morning, it was parked far from the store entrance.
Her husband John, a New York City firefighter, refused to allow police to search their properties.
He later had Norine declared legally deceased, remarried, and cut off her family’s access to their children. source
In May 2015, burglars broke into an isolated farmhouse in Askeaton, County Limerick, and found two decomposing bodies one was an Irish conwoman who had spent 40 years running scams across Britain, the US and Ireland under multiple identities before vanishing from police.
She was Cecilia McKitterick also known as Julia Holmes, and a dozen other names depending on which country she was in and who she needed to be.
By the time she was found, she had been dead long enough that her own identity had to be pieced together from records she had spent a lifetime burying. Her third husband, Thomas Ruttle, was found alongside her. No signs of forced entry. No obvious suspect.
A conwoman who outran law enforcement across Britain, the US, and Ireland for four decades found rotting in a farmhouse in Limerick with a man she may or may not have legally married. Source
In 1998, 16-year-old Tera Smith vanished in Redding, CA the same night she planned to end a secret affair with her married taekwondo instructor. He was 29, a convicted rapist, and the last person to see her alive. He gave one police interview and never spoke to investigators again.
Tera was 16, a homecoming queen who worked her family’s amusement center and kept journals she never finished. She told her sister she’d be back in 20 minutes. more details
On November 27, 1987, a woman lured 12-year-old Sian Kingi off her yellow bicycle in Noosa Heads by asking her to help find a lost poodle. Her husband grabbed Sian from behind. 6 days later she was found raped & stabbed 12 times, still in her school uniform, 17 days from her 13th birthday.
A fruit picker found her body six days later in a dry creek bed, still in her school uniform. She had been stabbed twelve times. Three of the wounds were driven through her heart. more details
In 1976, a 16-year-old was found near a Baltimore cemetery wrapped in a hospital sheet and sedated with a massive dose of chlorpromazine. She had no name for 45 years. A stranger’s 23andMe test identified her as Margaret Fetterolf. Her killer has never been found.
She had been beaten, sedated with chlorpromazine, strangled, and wrapped in a sheet consistent with inpatient psychiatric facility linens. A Ford Econoline van was seen nearby that morning. In 2006, semen was recovered from her clothing it led nowhere. More details
On January 31, 2013, Sasha Marsten, 16, went to a job interview at a Blackpool hotel arranged over Facebook. That night, her parents knocked on the same door looking for her. The man who answered said she had already left. He had stabbed her 58 times. Her body was yards away.
In 1993, Jennifer Odom, 12, got off her school bus in Florida and never made it the 200 yards to her front door. Her murder went cold for 30 years. Her killer was finally caught because his son was arrested for an unrelated crime and had to submit DNA that pointed back to his father.
Jennifer was a seventh-grader in rural Pasco County. Classmates on the bus watched a faded blue pickup follow her down the road.
Her body was found six days later in an orange grove 10 miles away. Crum was already serving two life sentences for a near-identical attack when he was indicted for her murder in 2023.
In 2001, Penn State student Cindy Song vanished after Halloween night. A man later confessed to killing her and even named where her body was buried. No evidence was ever found. It later emerged he had googled her case before going to police.
In June 1969, a ranger searching for missing 6-year-old Dennis Martin smelled what he was certain was a decomposing human body. His superiors told him it was a dead crow and ordered him away. Dennis was never found.
On August 26, 2017, Lloyd Neurauter told his daughter: “Help me kill your mother or watch me die.” She hid him in her trunk and drove 100 miles while her 14-year-old sister sat in the front seat. He put a towel in Michele’s mouth, strangled her, and staged the body as a suicide. She served 14 months
Lloyd was $100,000 in debt and owed Michele $6,000 monthly. He spent years convincing Karrie her mother was dangerous.
When he gave the ultimatum, Karrie believed every word. She helped stage the body, lied to police, and served 14 months. Lloyd got life without parole.
https://zedpulse.com/the-disturbing-story-of-lloyd-neurauter/
In 2004, Alonzo Brooks, 23, vanished after a party in rural Kansas where racial slurs were directed at him all night. Police ran six official searches over 28 days and found nothing. His family organized their own search, found his body in under an hour. Ruled a homicide. No one charged.
The FBI offered a $100,000 reward for information leading to an arrest and conviction in Brooks' death.