u/Hell-Consciousness45

لنقل اني بزمن الخلافة و غير مسلم و اجه شخص يريد يجعلني مسلم اذن كيف ، اعجاز علمي لا يوجد ، الله غير مرئي ، الرسول متوفي ، الصحابة متشاجرين ، المعجزات مجرد ورق و قلم ، تبقى مجرد القران و غالبا لن تقتنع به و اصلا لماذا الاقتناع بالقران يدل على الله اصلا و ما فائدة التواتر الان اذ القرآن كتب في عصري اي لنقل في عصر عثمان بعد ان أحرق جميع الكتب الاخرى و تم كتابة القران هذا بعد عشرين سنة من نقل الشفهي ، اذن ألم اشك هنا انا بالدين هذا، و بالاخير لنقل انني من غير لغة و بلد اذن ما هو الذي يجعلني اسلم

I see this as the most important criticism of Islam, and the reason I don't believe in it at all. I'm a former Shia Muslim, and I've encountered many arguments, but the argument about the eternity of Hell is the most hellish. 😅 Let's begin. Most sheikhs respond to the eternity of Hell by justifying it by saying that a murderer or a gang rapist should be in Hell because he deserves it. But I see this as merely an emotionally charged response that doesn't answer anything. Why isn't the rapist punished for just 100 or 1000 years? Why is the punishment eternal? Some philosophical sheikhs argue that one of the main reasons for the eternal damnation of sinners, especially atheists and polytheists, is that if they were to live forever on Earth, they would remain in their disbelief and misguidance, so they would be eternally condemned to Hell. Herein lies a problem: why would God create someone with a deterministic mindset who wouldn't change their mind, and why would He create them knowing they wouldn't succeed in the test? Based on this claim, we can understand that not all humans are equal; some are born with a mindset capable of conformity. God's commands and the commands of others are beyond human comprehension. Even setting all that aside, we return to a point everyone overlooks: why is the punishment absolute? Imagine that on Earth, you can't bear the pain of a needle prick, nor can you hold a cup of hot tea; even the strongest man can't endure that. So how can you possibly endure the pain of absolute black fire, inflicted by the Most Merciful God, for eternity? What is the point? How will the sinner, the atheist, the rapist, or the psychopath—whom God created psychopathically—learn from this punishment? I believe this argument is impossible to refute, indicating that the concept of fire is a very primitive notion devised by priests to frighten people. All this grandeur and beauty of the universe—would it contain an eternal furnace filled with testicle clips? 🤣 This is his opinion, and I'd appreciate yours.