I’m trying to find a good lip liner for overlining in 2026 and I feel like every recommendation I see is either super expensive or looks amazing on someone else but weird on me.
I’m not trying to do anything too dramatic, mostly just want something that makes my lips look a little fuller without that obvious drawn-on look. I’d love a liner that’s creamy enough to apply easily but not so soft that it smudges everywhere after an hour.
I’ve looked at a few popular ones, but now I’m confused about whether pencil, twist-up, or gel liners are better for this. I also don’t know if I should go slightly darker than my lips or match my natural lip color exactly.
For anyone who overlines regularly, what lip liner do you actually swear by? Bonus points if it lasts well and works for everyday makeup.
Thank you girls! So I ended up ordering the So Juicy Plumping Lip Liner which is incredible and also good price. The Mauve Lip Liner Pencil also seems to be popular here, especially if other lip liners look a bit too dark.