u/General_Fill_5450

Looking to getting a tile roof looked at and a sagging gutter replaced

The house is located in the northern Melbourne suburbs

Are the following quotes reasonable?

Quote 1 - Total $12,800 (incl. GST)

• Scope: full re-bedding and re-pointing of all ridge caps (flexi-point), replacement of all rusted valleys (storm sealed), full replacement of all gutters and downpipes around the property, and replacement of approx. 8m of metal roofing on extension.
• No Breakdown

Quote 2 - Total $8,540 (incl. GST)

• Scope: re-bed 26 caps, re-point 115 ridges, replace 3 valleys (13m), and replace rear side only gutters and downpipes.
• Breakdown:
  • Repoint ($2,875.00): Grind back mortar on approx. 115 ridges, supply flexi-point, repoint ridges and collars, and remove rubbish.
  • Rebedding ($1,950.00): Remove approx. 26 ridge caps and mortar; relay ridges using sand and cement with weep holes installed.
  • Valley Replacement ($1,820.00): Remove mortar, ridges, and tiles for 3 valleys (approx. 13m); install new Colorbond valleys and storm seal.
  • Gutters ($1,120.00): Replace rear side gutters (8m) and downpipes with overflow slots.