Trying to pick one and stop spending Sundays comparing pricing pages.
Use case: small consulting practice, 5-6 decks a month, mix of internal client decks and external proposals. Need something that handles design without me thinking about it. Need shared editing because two of us will use it. Need export to PDF that doesn't look broken.
I've trialed each of them in isolation but never head-to-head on the same content. Possible bias in every review I've read because reviewers usually picked one and stuck with it.
Specifically curious about three things.
Output quality on identical content. Does Gamma make a better looking deck than Pitch when fed the same outline.
Editing experience after generation. The AI generation is one part. Fixing the inevitable mistakes is the other part, and I've heard the editing in Gamma is friction-y for power users.
Real cost. The marketing pricing and the actual cost when you account for export limits, watermark removal, and team seats.
If anyone has actually run the same deck through 2 or all 3 — what did you find. Even a partial comparison helps.