Edit: Railfrugal is an app I built
I used Railfrugal, a price tracking tool for NEC trains, to run an experiment. For 5 days, I tracked prices on 3 major routes (Boston→NYC, NYC→DC, and DC→NYC) throughout the day within approximately 24 hours of train departure. In other words, I built my dataset from hundreds of price scrapes covering 514 unique train-day combinations. Here's what the data analysis shows.
How often do prices drop on the day of travel?
On the NYC↔DC corridor, 30–64% of trains dropped in price at some point on their day of departure, compared to what they were priced at first check. That's not a typo. This past Monday, 22 out of 36 (61%) NYC→DC trains dropped in price over the course of the day.
How much do they drop?
When a train price dropped, the average was $50–$120. The single biggest drop I recorded: a NYC→DC train that fell $308 in one day (from $461 to $128).
A few standouts:
- NYC→DC 3:04 PM: $152 at 10 AM → $57 by 2PM
- Boston→NYC 4:25 PM: held at $449 all day (some train prices don't budge)
- DC→NYC 2:00 PM: $212 → $136 by noon, then snapped back to $212 within the hour
What this means practically:
If you're booking super last minute (same-day or day-before) and have any flexibility on departure time, you may be leaving money on the table if you book when you first check prices. The catch: drops can disappear within minutes when someone else buys the seat.