Approved after NOID/204(c) concerns, now wondering if I really need an attorney again for I-751 Removal of Conditions?
Hey everyone,
I recently got my green card approved after one of the most stressful immigration experiences of my life, and now I’m trying to figure out whether hiring an attorney again for Removal of Conditions (I-751) in 2 years is really necessary or if people successfully do it themselves.
For context, I was previously married and later divorced. During my second marriage-based case, USCIS focused heavily on my prior marriage and issued a NOID basically implying my first marriage was not bona fide. What frustrated me the most is that our original application package was around 1,152 pages, and around 600+ pages were purely evidence-based (joint bank statements, leases, insurance, bills, photos, etc.). It honestly felt like they barely reviewed the full package and instead focused mainly on engagement photos they claimed looked “staged” because many were taken during the same photo session.
I ended up spending around $7,000 on an attorney to respond to the NOID. In the end, the response mostly involved:
quoting the law regarding INA 204(c), organizing the evidence better, adding sworn declarations, adding context/explanations to the photos, and re-submitting a lot of the same evidence that had already been filed.
Thankfully, both the I-130 and I-485 were approved, and I now have my conditional green card.
Here’s why I’m asking this question now: The day after my approval, the attorney’s office reached out wanting me to sign another contract for them to handle my I-751 Removal of Conditions in 2 years for around $4,000, even though I know the filing fee itself is around $750.
So I’m genuinely curious:
Did you file your I-751 yourself or with an attorney? If you did it yourself, was it difficult? Did anyone here have prior marriage scrutiny or a NOID before? Were you approved without issues? Is an attorney actually worth it for ROC if the current marriage is real and ongoing?
At this point I’m trying to balance peace of mind vs spending thousands again unnecessarily.
Would appreciate hearing real experiences from people who went through ROC themselves