u/Fahrezy

There is one thing I'm confused about the ryoshu ID teaser discussion. Is that people argue that she is either shiomi, araya, or even pinky nurse father. And I was like "aren't all this the same thing?"

Some araya ryoushu also makes argument that meursault is the shiomi because araya is ryoshu. But what is it going to be based on?

We never see the real shiomi fight in canto. She died before then, and shiomi was revealed to be araya. But araya's kit before and after the reveal are the same, and there are no way to know how the reaal shiomi fight, and if it's the same as araya. And even if Araya fight just like shiomi because she tried to be her or something, doesn't that just make two id's redundant?