“Warmth” of analogue synths due to recording?
I know there is some debate about whether you can actually hear the difference between analog synth or an emulation, like with the Mini Moog, and some pretty convincing videos online demonstrating that most people cannot distinguish.
I’ve been wondering though - is is possible that the difference we feel like we hear has more to do with the recording process itself and specifically the little bit of noise floor or hum you can get in analog recordings?
maybe I have a shitty interface or maybe I’m bad at recording, but the primary way I can tell with my own work is that I can actually hear when something is connected electrically. I can hear the little bit of noise, the slight fluctuations happening, and I am wondering if that sound, not the actual sound of synths, is what makes the analog sound more “real” and alive, because of the associations our brains have with people physically plugging something in?
is this anyone else’s experience or is everyone else getting perfect zero-noise pure recordings of their analog synths?