Ok not bad
I actually enjoyed this. My complaints are as follows:
-Garrett in the books LOVES hockey. It’s everything to him. And him not caring about it in the show takes away part of his drive-which is part of why Hannah loves him
-Jules was annoying and pointless, sorry.
- Phil should have been way more of a dick
-I wish the Halloween scene was a thing since it was pivotal. Garrett Waiting so long to tell Hannah about her dad defeated how they originally got together
-not happy about dean and allie but not mad either. I liked their scenes overall!
-Garrett and Hannah lacked chemistry. Dean and allie had ITT
-campus hands off rule: this I will not default from. It should’ve happened right. Really missing that charm from Garrett in this scene which makes him insufferable and loveable. I could say that for the whole show though-he needed to be more annoying/endearing towards her
-I also feel like their get together scene could’ve been more powerful, I didn’t feel like they were obsessed with each other yet
- the first kiss scene should’ve been with dean. They did NOT have to change that. That is my worst complaint
-if they were gonna do dean and allie, allie should not have slept with another guy. That literally defeats the whole purpose of her being in love with dean and a “nester”
Overall: 7/10