u/Daniboy0826

Are there any other European languages besides English, French and Irish that have a primarily etymological orthography rather than a phonetic one?

Most other spelling systems that I see on other European languages are very phonetic, English, French and Irish are the only ones that I notice that, above all, chose to preserve historical pronunciations instead of current ones, I might be wrong, though.

By the way, I'm specifying European ones because I know that outside of Europe, some languages like Vietnamese and Tibetan have varying degrees of etymology preservation too.

reddit.com
u/Daniboy0826 — 23 hours ago

Why do so many linguists say that Ы /ɨ/ is not phonemic in Russian?

When I found out that the most agreed upon vowel inventory for Russian was simply /a e i o u/, I was kinda shocked considering how many letters in the alphabet there were for vowels, but as I looked deep further, most of them were just for palatalization: Ю /ʲu/, Я /ʲa/...

Except for Ы which had its own [ɨ] sound dedicated to it? But apparently it is just an allophone for /i/? Doesn't it contrast with /i/ on words such as "и́кать" and "ы́кать"?

The Moscow school says that [ɨ] is not a phoneme, but the Saint-Petersburg phonology school says otherwise.

reddit.com
u/Daniboy0826 — 5 days ago