u/CullObsidian02

Round 40 of determining the Star Wars fandom tier list: Barriss Offee vs Aayla Secura

These duels are randomised from a small but ever growing pool of characters. Most upvoted responses will determine who scales higher, and both the detail of responses (and how mixed they are) will determine how far apart the characters should scale from one another. The intention is to be as reflective of general consensus as possible. Once sufficient characters are included, the tier list will be posted periodically for review, further discussion and collective amendment.

Back to this battle:

Round 1: Lightside Barriss (AOTC, CW2) vs Aayla Secura

Round 2: Darkside Barriss (CW5, TotE) vs Aayla Secura

Bonus round: where would you scale redeemed lightside Barriss as of TotE?

Any and all canon feats, statements and scaling are permitted for consideration for each round.

Combatants are in character. Win is by death or incapacitation.

Reminder - This isn't just about who wins, its about how far these characters scale apart as visualised on a tier list. Difficulty level is important.

Round 38 of determining the Star Wars fandom tier list: Asajj Ventress vs Qui Gon Jinn

These duels are randomised from a small but ever growing pool of characters. Most upvoted responses will determine who scales higher, and both the detail of responses (and how mixed they are) will determine how far apart the characters should scale from one another. The intention is to be as reflective of general consensus as possible. Once sufficient characters are included, the tier list will be posted periodically for review, further discussion and collective amendment.

Back to this battle:

Round 1: Qui Gon vs Early Acolyte Ventress (BH, CW Movie, CW 1)

Round 2: Qui Gon vs Late Acolyte Ventress (CW3)

Round 3: Qui Gon vs Bounty Hunter/Nightsister Ventress (CW 4/5)

Round 4: Qui Gon vs Prime Ventress (DD)

Round 5: Qui Gon vs Resurrected Ventress (BB, TotU)

Qui Gon is as of the PM for all rounds.

Any and all canon feats, statements and scaling are permitted for consideration for each round.

Combatants are in character. Win is by death or incapacitation.

Reminder - This isn't just about who wins, its about how far these characters scale apart as visualised on a tier list. Difficulty level is important.

Round 37 of determining the Star Wars fandom tier list: Rey Skywalker vs Kanan Jarrus

These duels are randomised from a small but ever growing pool of characters. Most upvoted responses will determine who scales higher, and both the detail of responses (and how mixed they are) will determine how far apart the characters should scale from one another. The intention is to be as reflective of general consensus as possible. Once sufficient characters are included, the tier list will be posted periodically for review, further discussion and collective amendment.

Back to this battle:

Round 1: FA/TLJ Rey vs Pre Injury Kanan

Round 2: ROS Rey vs Pre Injury Kanan

Round 3: FA/TLJ Rey vs Post Injury Kanan

Round 4: ROS Rey vs Post Injury Kanan

Rey does not get her 'All the Jedi' amp in this battle.

Any and all canon feats, statements and scaling are permitted for consideration for each round.

Combatants are in character. Win is by death or incapacitation.

Reminder - This isn't just about who wins, its about how far these characters scale apart as visualised on a tier list. Difficulty level is important.

Round 36 of determining the Star Wars fandom tier list: Ahsoka Tano vs Cere Junda

These duels are randomised from a small but ever growing pool of characters. Most upvoted responses will determine who scales higher, and both the detail of responses (and how mixed they are) will determine how far apart the characters should scale from one another. The intention is to be as reflective of general consensus as possible. Once sufficient characters are included, the tier list will be posted periodically for review, further discussion and collective amendment.

Back to this battle:

Both combatants are in their primes.

Any and all canon feats, statements and scaling are permitted for consideration for each round.

Combatants are in character. Win is by death or incapacitation.

Reminder - This isn't just about who wins, its about how far these characters scale apart as visualised on a tier list. Difficulty level is important.

Round 35 of determining the Star Wars fandom tier list: Shaak Tii vs Depa Billaba

These duels are randomised from a small but ever growing pool of characters. Most upvoted responses will determine who scales higher, and both the detail of responses (and how mixed they are) will determine how far apart the characters should scale from one another. The intention is to be as reflective of general consensus as possible. Once sufficient characters are included, the tier list will be posted periodically for review, further discussion and collective amendment.

Back to this battle:

For both combatants, they are in their respective primes as of the end of the Clone Wars.

Any and all canon feats, statements and scaling are permitted for consideration for each round.

Combatants are in character. Win is by death or incapacitation.

Reminder - This isn't just about who wins, its about how far these characters scale apart as visualised on a tier list. Difficulty level is important.

Round 34 of determining the Star Wars fandom tier list: Obi Wan Kenobi & Anakin Skywalker vs Darth Vader

These duels are randomised from a small but ever growing pool of characters. Most upvoted responses will determine who scales higher, and both the detail of responses (and how mixed they are) will determine how far apart the characters should scale from one another. The intention is to be as reflective of general consensus as possible. Once sufficient characters are included, the tier list will be posted periodically for review, further discussion and collective amendment.

Back to this battle:

Round 1: Early Suit Vader (19-14BBY)

Round 2: Dark Times Vader (14-1BBY)

Round 3: Prime Vader (0-4ABY)

For both rounds, Anakin and Obi Wan are as of their primes in ROTS.

Any and all canon feats, statements and scaling are permitted for consideration for each round.

Combatants are in character. Win is by death or incapacitation.

Reminder - This isn't just about who wins, its about how far these characters scale apart as visualised on a tier list. Difficulty level is important.

Round 34 of determining the Star Wars fandom tier list: Obi Wan Kenobi vs Anakin Skywalker vs Ahsoka Tano (Padawan levels)

These duels are randomised from a small but ever growing pool of characters. Most upvoted responses will determine who scales higher, and both the detail of responses (and how mixed they are) will determine how far apart the characters should scale from one another. The intention is to be as reflective of general consensus as possible. Once sufficient characters are included, the tier list will be posted periodically for review, further discussion and collective amendment.

Back to this battle:

Round 1: Mid War Ahsoka (CW 3/4/5)

Round 2: Late CW Ahsoka (CW 7)

For both rounds, Anakin and Obi Wan are at the peak of their respective apprenticeships.

For Obi Wan, this is as of his defeat of Darth Maul in PM.

For Anakin Skywalker, this is as of his first battle with Count Dooku in AOTC.

Any and all canon feats, statements and scaling are permitted for consideration for each round.

Combatants are in character. Win is by death or incapacitation.

Reminder - This isn't just about who wins, its about how far these characters scale apart as visualised on a tier list. Difficulty level is important.

Round 33 of determining the Star Wars fandom tier list: Qui Gon Jinn vs Yaddle.

These duels are randomised from a small but ever growing pool of characters. Most upvoted responses will determine who scales higher, and both the detail of responses (and how mixed they are) will determine how far apart the characters should scale from one another. The intention is to be as reflective of general consensus as possible. Once sufficient characters are included, the tier list will be posted periodically for review, further discussion and collective amendment.

Back to this battle:

Both characters are as of their respective Phantom Menace/TOTJ levels.

Any and all canon feats, statements and scaling are permitted for consideration for each round.

Combatants are in character. Win is by death or incapacitation.

Reminder - This isn't just about who wins, its about how far these characters scale apart as visualised on a tier list. Difficulty level is important.

Round 32 of determining the Star Wars fandom tier list: Darth Maul vs Quinlan Vos.

These duels are randomised from a small but ever growing pool of characters. Most upvoted responses will determine who scales higher, and both the detail of responses (and how mixed they are) will determine how far apart the characters should scale from one another. The intention is to be as reflective of general consensus as possible. Once sufficient characters are included, the tier list will be posted periodically for review, further discussion and collective amendment.

Back to this battle:

Round 1: Sith Apprentice (PM) Maul vs Quinlan Vos

Round 2: Prime (CW) Maul vs Quinlan Vos

Round 3: Dark Times (Shadow Lord/Rebels) Maul vs Quinlan Vos

For all rounds, Quinlan Vos is as of his prime following his training under Count Dooku and Asajj Ventress in Dark Diciple.

As a bonus round, feel free to scale his pre darkside training levels to Maul as well.

Any and all canon feats, statements and scaling are permitted for consideration for each round.

Combatants are in character. Win is by death or incapacitation.

Reminder - This isn't just about who wins, its about how far these characters scale apart as visualised on a tier list. Difficulty level is important.

Round 31 of determining the Star Wars fandom tier list: Plo Koon & Adi Gallia vs Shaak Tii & Kit Fisto.

These duels are randomised from a small but ever growing pool of characters. Most upvoted responses will determine who scales higher, and both the detail of responses (and how mixed they are) will determine how far apart the characters should scale from one another. The intention is to be as reflective of general consensus as possible. Once sufficient characters are included, the tier list will be posted periodically for review, further discussion and collective amendment.

Back to this battle:

All combatants are in their primes.

Any and all canon feats, statements and scaling are permitted for consideration for each round.

Combatants are in character. Win is by death or incapacitation.

Bonus round: Rank each character from strongest to weakest in their primes.

Reminder - This isn't just about who wins, its about how far these characters scale apart as visualised on a tier list. Difficulty level is important.

Second attempt to post due to awful formatting:

1. this is reflective of results from my VS battles. It is not inherently reflective of my views. I disagree with a decent number of placements actually.

2. feel free to question certain placements. This is not an exact science and I want it to reflect general opinion. I will try to explain placements as best as I can. Sufficiently agreed upon arguments for characters to scale higher/lower will be taken into account when allocating placements on future versions.

3. I am aware the image quality can be questionable, so I will also post the tierlist in longform in the comments.

Let me know what your thoughts are!

Round 30 of determining the Star Wars fandom tier list: Maul & Savage Opress vs Count Dooku & Asajj Ventress

These duels are randomised from a small but ever growing pool of characters. Most upvoted responses will determine who scales higher, and both the detail of responses (and how mixed they are) will determine how far apart the characters should scale from one another. The intention is to be as reflective of general consensus as possible. Once sufficient characters are included, the tier list will be posted periodically for review, further discussion and collective amendment.

Back to this battle:

Round 1: Each combatant is as of their primes AS master/apprentice duos. For Maul & Savage, this is as of their confrontation with Sidious on Mandalore in CW5. For Dooku & Ventress, this is as of Dooku betraying Ventress during the battle of Sullust in CW3.

Round 2: All characters are in their absolute primes.

- for Maul, this has been pretty contentious of late. I'll leave it to you all to decide when this is for yourselves. Make your arguments.

- for Savage, this should be as of CW5.

- for Dooku, this should be as of ROTS.

- for Ventress, this should be as of Dark Diciple.

Bonus round: Rank each character from strongest to weakest in their primes.

Any and all canon feats, statements and scaling are permitted for consideration for each round.

Combatants are in character. Win is by death or incapacitation.

Reminder - This isn't just about who wins, its about how far these characters scale apart as visualised on a tier list. Difficulty level is important.

A Petranaki classic:

Round 29 of determining the Star Wars fandom tier list: Darth Sidious vs Darth Maul & Darth Tyranus

These duels are randomised from a small but ever growing pool of characters. Most upvoted responses will determine who scales higher, and both the detail of responses (and how mixed they are) will determine how far apart the characters should scale from one another. The intention is to be as reflective of general consensus as possible. Once sufficient characters are included, the tier list will be posted periodically for review, further discussion and collective amendment.

Back to this battle:

Round 1: Sidious, Dooku and Maul are all as of their Peak CW levels. Battle takes place in the throne room of Mandalore.

Round 2: Sidious, Dooku and Maul are all in their primes. Battle takes place in the throne room of Exegol.

Combatants are in character. Win is by death or incapacitation.

Reminder - it isn't just about who wins. It's about how far these characters scale apart. Difficulty level is important.

Round 28 of determining the Star Wars fandom tier list: Qui Gon Jinn vs Obi Wan Kenobi

These duels are randomised from a small but ever growing pool of characters. Most upvoted responses will determine who scales higher, and both the detail of responses (and how mixed they are) will determine how far apart the characters should scale from one another. The intention is to be as reflective of general consensus as possible. Once sufficient characters are included, the tier list will be posted periodically for review, further discussion and collective amendment.

Back to this battle:

Rounds:

1. AOTC/BH Obi Wan vs Qui Gon

2. Early CW Obi Wan (CW Movie, CW S1/2) vs Qui Gon

3. Mid War Obi Wan (CW 3/4/5) vs Qui Gon

4. Late War Obi Wan (CW 6, DD) vs Qui Gon

5. ROTS Obi Wan vs Qui Gon

6. Old Ben vs Qui Gon

Qui Gon is as of the Phantom Menace for all rounds.

Combatants are in character. Win is by death or incapacitation.