Probably on my 20th-ish listen. Here are my honest rankings of each song. Obviously opinion based. Feel free to torch me in the comments <3
Scale of 6:
0 - Bad (unlistenable)
1 - Meh (below average. Skip)
2 - Decent (Passable, but basically filler)
3 - Good (don’t dislike it, but not revisiting)
4 - great (going on my playlist)
5 - Amazing (Best of the best)
6 - Obsessed (Im gonna listen to this so much it’ll be a problem)
The Great Divide: 6
All them Horses: 5.5
End of August: 5
Porch Light: 5
Headed North: 4.5
Orbiter: 4.5
Downfall: 4
23: 4
Dan: 4
Dashboard: 4
Paid Time Off: 4
Deny deny deny: 4
Staying still: 3.5
Haircut: 3
Willing & Able: 3
American cars: 3
Doors: 2.5
Lighthouse: 2.5
A few of your own: 2.5
Spoiled: 1.5
We go way back: 1.5
Overall felt the album was a little bloated for my taste, but I’m sure some of the ones I ranked lower are really connecting with some fans. And I’m a guy on reddit so wtf do I know.