Pls send help no Agenda. Ngl, I am currently struggling to find a good tier for several characters. Right now wherever I put Loki, Shamrock, Franky, Crocodile and Beckman it always just feels off to me. Pls help
I think obvious and unarguable placements on any tier list are:
- Imu above everyone else
- Shanks a tier above Gorosei
- Admirals above Holy Knights but below Gorosei
- Zoro and Sanji are closing in on Admirals
- Kuzan/Kizaru/Greenbull etc a couple of tiers above weaker commanders
- Mihawk above Zoro
I'm struggling to place
Loki: because I want to put him higher, but I don't want to even put Luffy as high as he is right now. And I believe narratively they should be neck and neck. Maybe Ragnir makes up the difference in power? and it's fine keeping Loki a little lower as long as Ragnir is making up for it....
Shamrock: everytime I put him below Loki it looks incorrect. But every time I put him above the Gorosei it looks even worse.... this one is hard bc it's just the one statement he makes....
Franky: now that he's gotten a big power boost I know he needs to be on some sort of commander tier. The thing is it seems weird to put him below Jinbe.... but at the same time I don't want to jump him up 2 tiers from where he was and also that far away from Robin in power. Maybe he just is now though??? any help here is appreciated.
Crocodile: he's done literally nothing to put him on par with Admirals or Sanji.... and when Lucci came back he was much stronger than before but still clearly weaker than Zoro. I think Marineford showed Crocodile can fight an Admiral but definitely not win.... do we really think he deserves to be this high on a list? I also feel like whenever I move him too far below Mihawk it doesn't make sense at all....
Beckman: I just don't want to put him too far away from Shanks because it would make no sense that Shanks would be able to one shot his Vice Captain. When Roger and Rayleigh are supposed to be similar enough in power. but then when I move Beckman up more he's suddenly on par with Mihawk which also doesn't look right to me... I know this one is the most speculation, but curious to hear though on him too.
thank you!