u/Coolguy-78

My friend and I were building the best possible lineup for brewers post 2000 choosing a player from one specific season and we genuinely can’t decide on catcher. In your opinion, who was better?

Lucroy- 153 games, 6.4 WAR, .301/.373/.465
13 HR, 69 RBI, fourth in MVP voting

Bill- 155 games, 5.0 WAR, .281/.365/.466
23 HR, 92 RBI, fifth in MVP voting