I spent the past 2 days obsessively reviewing my recent, fervently-awaited Poesie order! I hadn’t ordered from them since like 2021, but I’ve had a pretty high hit rate with their scents in the past and I wanted to try some new and new-to-me perfumes. I branched out a little from my typical comfort zone (I have historically been a big fan of their Ghost scents) with some of these choices, and my experience was mixed, but I expected that!
Shipping took a while- I think 6 weeks or so, door-to-door, because my order contained two Lucky Day scents (Emmeline Pankhurst and Noir Inayat Khan). Packaging was nice and I got a couple of sample freebies.
Winners: Green Girl (will probably FS later on), Noor Inayat Khan, Oyster!
Maybes: Titania (I want to try this in an edp), Rich Ghost, Weighted Blanket
****
Emmeline Pankhurst
Black tea swirled with vanilla cream, cold rain on stone, soft linen, cozy musk
Black tea HEAVY on the cream with sweet vanilla musk and petrichor. It’s kind of like… an indoor version of Solstice Scents Sea of Gray (here I go again). If Sea of Gray is standing on a cold beach eating a vanilla ice cream cone, this is sitting inside the beach house in a window seat with a cup of tea and a book, watching the rain outside. Unfortunately there’s just not enough of the most interesting notes- the rain, the stone; it just ends up smelling like that very typical Poesie vanilla musk, and it fades FAST, after about 30 minutes.
Full Moon (at the Temple)
Fragrant white rice, shiso leaf, bitter yuzu zest, hinoki wood, green tea, and lakewater
This made me VIOLENTLY SNEEZE for about 10 minutes, before it completely faded. Before my nose became completely blocked by whatever it is in here that I am clearly allergic to, I smelled petrichor and a similar rice note to Soft, as well as something very “fresh” which made me think of a pleasantly scented candle. Clearly, this is not worth the risk of anaphylaxis, lol. But for once I am glad that my skin chemistry tends to absolutely devour scents, because it literally is already totally gone!
Green Girl
Pistachio, wildflower honey, oat milk matcha latte, heliotrope blossoms, and marshmallow musk
It’s taken me a few tries to warm up to Green Girl (it probably doesn’t help that my first sniff was straight out of the mailbox, because I have always secretly believed that perfume needing to “rest” is a myth, even though this kind of proves that it probably isn’t lol). It was a free random sample but I don’t know why, because I love matcha scents and if I had noticed it, I would have wanted to try it. ANYWAY, I’ve really come to like it! It has surprising throw and longevity. I can really smell the creamy oat milk and the sweet grassy matcha; I get less pistachio than expected, but there is a bit of nuttiness. There’s also the really sweet, floral heliotrope in the background and a soft musk. I think I will grab an edp sample of this in my next Poesie order because I can really see it shining in that format.
Madar
Comforting, creamy basmati rice pudding flavored with orange flower water, saffron, cinnamon, cardamom, dried rose petals, and sugared pistachios
At first sniff, this is SO good, a very realistic creamy rice pudding with spices (mostly cardamom) and hints of sweet, light rose/orange flower. I love how cozy and creamy it smells. I’m obsessed with rice notes right now, and this is pretty perfect. Unfortunately I get NO longevity. It fades pretty quickly to a toasty-creamy-nutty skin scent, very subtle. I wish it lasted longer on my skin!
Montmartre
Dappled sunlight on warm skin, a splash of absinthe in a glass and a twist of bergamot peel, a cool spring breeze, lavender buds, and violet leaf
Sweetly fresh, delicately herbal (mostly lavender) but very subtle- like clean freshly-showered skin, after you’ve used a bunch of fancy hotel bath products. I would like this in a lotion or linen spray, but it doesn’t have the oomph I am looking for in a perfume. It smells REALLY good on my husband, but it faded very quickly for both of us.
Noor Inayat Khan
Rich butter cookies, heady jasmine blossom, bright cardamom
At first sniff it smells like warm rice? Then the cookie note starts to develop- sweet buttery cardamom-scented cookies, with a very sweet, non-indolic jasmine on top. The jasmine really blooms as I wear it and it becomes so heady and rich. The cookie notes don’t take it into overly foodie territory- they are very much in the background, a toasty-warm base with the sweet jasmine on top. The late dry down is all toasty spice with a light pretty jasmine. It has pretty good longevity! This was a blind buy FS for me and I’m glad I took the chance on it.
Oyster!
Grey musk, ocean brine, bitter cucumber, a twist of lemon, elemi resin, and angelica
Oyster is so unique! On one hand, it is pretty much what it says on the tin- a light clean musk with plenty of water, both salty and sweet, with hints of lemon peel and cucumber freshness- but on the other, Oyster! is much greater than the sum of its parts. It’s a really interesting aquatic- I imagine this would be perfect for hot weather, but it also makes me think of visiting the beach on a chilly, windswept day. It’s fresh and so salty you can almost taste it on your tongue, with a bit of delicious sweetness as well. The angelica root really seems to come out on the dry down, a little earthy and woody underneath all that ocean water. I’m really impressed with its longevity, since it’s such a light watery scent! I had this years ago and missed it- so glad I full sized.
Rich Ghost
Iso E Super, ruby red grapefruit, rich sandalwood, golden threads of saffron, a hint of jasmine perfume, grey musk, warm amber, and marshmallow
Why does this smell so good, and so strangely familiar? At first it’s all gooey marshmallow, musk and rich woods… then the notes all start to coalesce and I realize it’s basically Baccarat Rouge 540 + marshmallow, which, it turns out, was the magic ingredient missing from the original all along. Sweet, musky, ambery marshmallow goodness, and it lasts for ages.
Soft
Basmati rice soliflore
Ok… Soft confuses me IMMENSELY because I love the rice note in Madar; it’s so realistic and delicious and this… smells nothing like any type of rice, let alone basmati????? It’s a really pleasant scent, but it’s just not rice. Instead I get a cool, slightly creamy musk? It makes me think of a really nice, faintly scented moisturizer.
After like 30 minutes I start to actually sort of get the rice note but it’s quite sweet and strongly reminds me of horchata, but it’s not exactly photorealistic- it specifically smells like a horchata-scented lotion. Not quite what I was looking for here!
Titania
Blonde woods, sparkling bergamot, orange creamsicle, magnolia, and stargazer lily
I kept going back and forth on Titania! Initially, I wasn’t impressed. On the second try, I really like it. It’s a really pretty floral that is tempered from being too heavy or heady by the creamy citrus and “sparkling” notes. It really has a slight fizz to it! Before I looked at the description, I actually thought there was (non-indolic) jasmine in here, but I guess it’s the magnolia/lily combo playing tricks on my nose. It smells elegant and tropical… I want to wear this on vacation in Hawaii or something. I think the website description is accurate in that this could be a gateway floral for floral-haters (I used to be one!). The problem for me is the dry down… it flattens out, becomes more dry wood and light floral, and starts to smell a little bit, let’s say, Bath and Body Works. (I don’t even hate B&BW, but it’s not what I buy indie perfumes to smell like!) HOWEVER, I’m adding onto this a little later because even later on, it evolved again to a very creamy citrus floral, and now I am liking it again. This is another scent I think I need to try in an edp, because I think the notes will work better on my skin in that format.
Weighted Blanket
Cozy vanilla musk, warm cardamom, airy vanilla bean, your favorite fluffy blanket, freshly laundered linen sheets
This one reminds me a lot of an older Poesie scent I have, Cardigan. It’s got that same fuzzy musky softness, but it’s much drier and less creamy. Weighted Blanket is very very cozy, soft and warm and does successfully evoke comfy blankets and linens without smelling like laundry detergent! The cardamom is super subtle, almost nonexistent. Surprising throw and longevity! I would consider a full size if I didn’t already have and love Cardigan.
Yet to Be Written
a warm cup of cinnamon chestnut black tea, stacks of books, white oud, ink stained fingers, a wisp of black amber
A really strong cup of a tannic black tea with a papery musk in the background. That's about it! I’m not getting any cinnamon or ink (too bad, because I love Poesie’s ink note, especially in Library Ghost!) or oud. It’s pretty much just tea, and it smells good, but doesn’t interest me a whole lot. Medium throw, doesn’t last very long.