To start, I’m not saying that investing is pointless!
But I think I’m confused on how people approach spending. I’ve always heard that rich people don’t actually have a lot of liquid cash, they just have a lot of different assets. I’ve also heard that you shouldn’t hold the bulk of your money in a normal checking or savings account because it doesn’t keep up with inflation. So I thought everyone financially savvy is keeping all of their money in investments and taking it out when they’re ready to spend it on nice things they can afford as their financial status improves.
I posted in another forum asking how people account for taxes when they withdraw from their taxable brokerage account for expenses, like say you’re planning a really nice two week vacation next year and you want to take out cash to pay for that. I basically got a ton of messages saying no one takes money out of their brokerage for that kind of expense, and people basically just let their money sit in their brokerage either for retirement or for a much bigger further out expense like decades down the line. Which kind of seems like a hoarding mindset - we’re just holding money to let it grow so that we can hold onto more money?
Everyone who replied said expenses within a few years would come from either their checking or their HYSA, but I thought the whole point of the brokerage was to have all your money work and grow so that you can spend and enjoy your returns? I know I’ve heard multiple people say you shouldn’t keep anything in your checking or savings account except for monthly expenses on auto pay. I’m having a very hard time conceptualizing these two different pieces of advice. Sorry if this is rambling, appreciate any clarity y’all can give.