u/CommitteeChemical530

▲ 4 r/ww1

How would WW1 have gone if Russia was Germany's ally from the Start

The Treaty of Björkö was a plan by Kaiser Wilhelm II to secure Russia as an ally. It was never ratified due to opposition from influential political circles on both sides, mainly because it conflicted with Russia’s existing alliance commitments with France. But what if it had been ratified? What if, in 1905, Germany and Russia had actually become allies? Now, I have a few questions. Would this drastically change the lead-up to World War I in any way? Russia and Austria had fought over influence in the Balkans for decades—would Austria have been okay with Germany aligning itself with Russia? And what happens to Serbia? Would Germany value Russia more than Austria and essentially say, “forget it—Serbia can do whatever it wants; we want the larger empire as our ally”? And assuming events unfold similarly otherwise, how would World War I change? Personally, I think it might turn into a massive push toward Paris in 1914. Britain could still join, but if the Central Powers gained more ground early on, it might end up being Germany, Russia, Austria, and Italy against France and Britain. What do you think.

reddit.com

What if Grand Duke George Alexandrovich Romanov became Tsar

For this to even be a possibility, the Ōtsu Incident—an attempted assassination of Nicholas, then the Tsarevich of Russia, in 1891. My questions are: would this seriously damage Russian–Japanese relations? Would Alexander III of Russia have sought aggression against Japan? And the main question: what kind of tsar would Grand Duke George Alexandrovich have been? Assuming the historical timeline remains the same, he would have only about five years on the throne before dying of tuberculosis, after which Grand Duke Michael Alexandrovich would become tsar. At that point, from 1881 to 1899, four tsars would have ruled in a relatively short span of time. Would this lead to instability or even attempts at revolution? What do you think.

reddit.com
u/CommitteeChemical530 — 3 days ago

Did the Lady Mary and other Catholics know Edward was being raised a protestant

“I’ve been wondering about this lately. Edward and Mary had a pretty good relationship until he became king, and after Edward Seymour’s death, his regency council tried to stop her from attending Mass in Latin. So did she know he was being raised as a Protestant? It also seems kind of counterproductive for Bishop Gardiner to hunt down Protestants if he knew the next king was being trained as one. That wouldn’t exactly be a smart way to keep his head.

reddit.com
u/CommitteeChemical530 — 4 days ago