Do some readers think a book being labelled "Adult" is like a film being "Rated R"?
Asking because I'm an author, and a surprising number of Goodreads reviewers have expressed confusion over my book's Adult categorization, which was assigned by the publisher.
This has been confusing to me in turn, since the book has a 40-year-old protagonist whose age is quite necessary for the story, so it absolutely could not have been categorized as YA (which requires a teen protagonist!). I've been so puzzled what exactly people think an adult title is supposed to be like, since the reviewers are mostly nonspecific about it.
Finally it clicked that people are phrasing their confusion as if they think Adult vs YA vs MG is a content warning system like MPAA ratings. Certainly if the book were a film, it would be rated PG-13. Is that what people think?