What would it take to bring me back to Windows
Like a growing number of people, I switched to Linux at the start of this year, and so far, I have not had the want or need to use Windows again. Here's what I'd do to get people back. And no, I won't just say 'remove Copilot'. Instead, I want to make it work:
I would prioritise making a new OS from the ground up. When Apple went from Mac OS Classic to OS X, it was exactly the change that Apple needed. We have use NT based Windows now for LONGER than DOS-based Windows. It's time to make the future version of windows. Year zero, build an emulator to allow you to use older software, and maybe make one more NT-Based Windows OS before the transition.
Make computing sustainable. The shift from 10 to 11 has seen too many good PC's turn into landfill. We cannot continue with that. the next version of windows should run on every windows 11 PC. You download it, and it just works. With that, you can lower system requirements. If there is a RAM shortage, maybe try making a version of Windows that works well on 8GB of RAM.
Sell Windows again. Stop offering it for free as an upgrade. It allows you to reduce the ads. Also.
When you install Windows, just start with the basic OS and Apps. Edge, the Store, File Explorer, Paint, Notepad, Calculator. Then, when you go through the OOTB experience, you get the option to install Microsoft 365. Just a check box. Then you have recommended apps right there while you're installing, not on your start menu.
Integrate Power toys features. The spotlight search should just be a feature on Windows at this point.
The UI should be simple. Taskbar is just the taskbar, and not clogged up with widgets. Have widgets on your screen, bring back Windows gadgets.