Hey everybody, Luke with After Eden (again, two posts in one day!)
Today, I wanted to talk about ancestry design using orcs as the sharpest example of what we are trying to do. In After Eden, the progenitor ancestries, which are the primary player ancestries, were not created by a single pantheon or from one shared template. Humans, orcs, elves, and dwarves were each created by their own god, in their own god’s image, and each developed in a separate realm with cultures that formed independently from one another. Nox, the default setting of After Eden, is the human realm, previously known as Eden. Many of the other progenitor peoples now live there after fleeing their own realms, but that is something we will talk about another day.
The design goal is to make sure orcs are not humans with tusks, elves are not humans with long ears, and dwarves are not humans with beards and a mining culture stapled onto them. Instead, we want each ancestry to have its own psychological profile shaped by species physiology, divine origin, and independent cultural development. If these peoples were created by different gods, in different realms, under different conditions, then they should not all relate to the world like slightly altered humans.
Orcs are probably the most controversial expression of that design philosophy, and they are the ancestry I want to focus on today. In After Eden, orcs are driven by conflict. Their bodies adapt to challenge, resistance, hardship, and victory. Their physiology is constantly changing in response to what they survive, what they overcome, and what they consume from defeated enemies.
Consuming monsters and dangerous creatures probably is not controversial for most fantasy tables. The more controversial part is that orcs may also consume parts of defeated sapient enemies. That is an intentional piece of the setting, but the goal is not to present orcs as evil by default. For many orcs, refusing to take anything from a worthy enemy after killing them can itself be seen as dishonor. If the enemy was strong enough to challenge you, then part of them is worth carrying forward.
There is an honor culture in many orc societies, but it is not just about glory or violence for its own sake. Orcs pursue challenge because challenge improves them and improves the people around them. Competition, rivalry, combat, endurance, and hardship are not only signs of hatred or ideological opposition. They can also be ways of testing one another, strengthening one another, almost in a roundabout parental or brotherly way. Like when a parent throws their child into a pool to teach them to swim.
As hinted earlier, different orc lineages consume different parts of defeated creatures and understand those parts as windows into different kinds of growth. Some orcs consume flesh, some consume blood, some consume hearts, and some consume minds. Each lineage draws different traits from what it consumes, based on the nature of the creature defeated and the part of that creature taken into the orc’s body.
The other reason orcs need challenge is because their bodies do not only adapt to hardship. They also adapt to stagnation. If an orc does not pursue a life of challenge, danger, pressure, and growth, their body begins to degenerate over time. Their adaptive nature turns inward, overcorrecting in the absence of resistance. This means orc cultures naturally value strength, cunning, resilience, ambition, and a willingness to seek out hardship rather than avoid it.
That is part of why we think orcs will make great player characters, but also great enemies and interesting NPCs. They are built for adventure in a very literal sense. Their biology pushes them toward challenge, their cultures give that challenge meaning, and their lineages give players different ways to express what it means for an orc to overcome something and become changed by it.
Our goal for After Eden is to have a shorter list of ancestries with deeper lineage design, rather than a huge list of options that mostly feel like cosmetic variations. Orcs currently have four different lineages, and we will talk more about the design of the other ancestries as we get closer to releasing the player playtest packet and adventure playtest packet.
I hope you found this interesting. Is this kind of ancestry design a turnoff for you, or does it make the world feel more distinct? How do you handle different peoples, species, races, or ancestries in your own games? Let us know your thoughts, feel free to ask questions, and we will see you in the next one.