u/Bisexual-Ninja

lets say you play a coin toss with god, and the coin has 3 sides.

god lets you know, that 1 side of the coin is definetly not going to land on.

in the monty hall problem, you should switch, because that's the better probability, however, because god said so, it's effectively the same 50/50 as the original conclusion.

now you and god picked diff coin sides, with both of you knowing that the 3rd isn't going to land.

the choice was meaningless because god knew what side the coin is going to land on.

unless we are arguing that humans have the power of a god, to know what side the coin is not going to land on, then the choice is always 50/50. regardless of results.