u/ArticleSilent7403

▲ 2 r/SaaS

My users abandoned my app immediately, here is what I learned

About 5 months ago I decided to build an app for myself because I was tired of checking 10 different freelance platforms every day just to find decent gigs.

That was the original problem.

Not productivity.

Not project management.

Not "the future of freelancing."

Just:

"finding relevant jobs is annoying and time consuming."

So I built a system that aggregated jobs from different sources, generated vector embeddings for them, then compared them against embeddings generated from my own profile to score jobs from 0-1 based on relevance and skill match.

Then I added an AI proposal generator that used:

* the job post

* my profile

* my skills/experience

to generate proposals I could copy and paste directly into listings.

Honestly, that should have been the product.

But then I started doing what I think a lot of technical founders do:

I confused "more features" with "more value."

So the app slowly mutated into this giant freelance super app.

First:

* a kanban board

Then:

* project management

Then:

* CRM

Then:

* contract generator

Then:

* resume generator

Then:

* resume analyzer

Then:

* event calendar

And suddenly I was building an entire freelance operating system instead of solving the actual problem I started with.

The worst part?

Most of those features were half baked because I was spreading myself too thin.

Then came launch day.

I posted it on Reddit.

People signed up.

Some even completed onboarding.

Then they landed on the dashboard...

and disappeared forever.

No return.

No engagement.

Nothing.

At first that felt horrible.

But honestly, it was probably the best thing that could have happened.

Because it forced me to stop romanticizing the product and actually look at reality.

The original app had a very clear promise:

* find better jobs faster

* apply faster

That was it.

Everything else diluted the core experience.

Users do not care about your grand vision when they first open your app.

They care about whether they immediately understand:

"What does this do for me right now?"

And I realized another thing:

all the extra AI features were massively increasing complexity and projected costs.

I kept delaying launch because I thought I would need huge amounts of AI credits to sustain the app.

After stripping everything back down to the original 2 features:

* job matching

* AI proposal generation

my AI costs became almost negligible.

Like genuinely tiny.

The app became cheaper to run, easier to maintain, easier to understand, and honestly just... better.

This whole thing taught me something important:

A product is not a collection of features.

A product is a focused solution to a painful problem.

And every extra feature carries hidden costs:

* UX complexity

* onboarding friction

* maintenance

* debugging

* cognitive load

* slower iteration

* harder messaging

I think a lot of us developers fall into this trap because building features feels productive.

But users do not reward complexity.

They reward clarity and usefulness.

Anyway, still building.

Still learning.

But cutting features was probably one of the best product decisions I have made so far.

reddit.com
u/ArticleSilent7403 — 5 days ago

My users abandoned my app immediately, here is what I learned [AMA]

About 5 months ago I decided to build an app for myself because I was tired of checking 10 different freelance platforms every day just to find decent gigs.

That was the original problem.

Not productivity.
Not project management.
Not "the future of freelancing."

Just:
"finding relevant jobs is annoying and time consuming."

So I built a system that aggregated jobs from different sources, generated vector embeddings for them, then compared them against embeddings generated from my own profile to score jobs from 0-1 based on relevance and skill match.

Then I added an AI proposal generator that used:

  • the job post
  • my profile
  • my skills/experience

to generate proposals I could copy and paste directly into listings.

Honestly, that should have been the product.

But then I started doing what I think a lot of technical founders do:
I confused "more features" with "more value."

So the app slowly mutated into this giant freelance super app.

First:

  • a kanban board

Then:

  • project management

Then:

  • CRM

Then:

  • contract generator

Then:

  • resume generator

Then:

  • resume analyzer

Then:

  • event calendar

And suddenly I was building an entire freelance operating system instead of solving the actual problem I started with.

The worst part?
Most of those features were half baked because I was spreading myself too thin.

Then came launch day.

I posted it on Reddit.

People signed up.
Some even completed onboarding.

Then they landed on the dashboard...
and disappeared forever.

No return.
No engagement.
Nothing.

At first that felt horrible.
But honestly, it was probably the best thing that could have happened.

Because it forced me to stop romanticizing the product and actually look at reality.

The original app had a very clear promise:

  • find better jobs faster
  • apply faster

That was it.

Everything else diluted the core experience.

Users do not care about your grand vision when they first open your app.
They care about whether they immediately understand:
"What does this do for me right now?"

And I realized another thing:
all the extra AI features were massively increasing complexity and projected costs.

I kept delaying launch because I thought I would need huge amounts of AI credits to sustain the app.

After stripping everything back down to the original 2 features:

  • job matching
  • AI proposal generation

my AI costs became almost negligible.
Like genuinely tiny.

The app became cheaper to run, easier to maintain, easier to understand, and honestly just... better.

This whole thing taught me something important:
A product is not a collection of features.

A product is a focused solution to a painful problem.

And every extra feature carries hidden costs:

  • UX complexity
  • onboarding friction
  • maintenance
  • debugging
  • cognitive load
  • slower iteration
  • harder messaging

I think a lot of us developers fall into this trap because building features feels productive.

But users do not reward complexity.
They reward clarity and usefulness.

Anyway, still building.
Still learning.
But cutting features was probably one of the best product decisions I have made so far.

reddit.com
u/ArticleSilent7403 — 5 days ago

I’ve been working on Freyo, and I wanted to share it here with people who actually understand the grind of finding work online.

Freyo is a job and freelance gig feed that pulls listings from popular job boards and freelancing sites, then uses AI to rank them against your profile. Instead of endless scrolling through noise, you only see opportunities that actually match what you’re looking for.

The goal is simple: less time searching, more time applying to the right things.

I built this mainly for freelancers hunting gigs and people actively looking for jobs. The problem I kept running into (and I’m sure many of you do too) is that most platforms just throw everything at you, relevant or not.

With Freyo, you basically get a filtered feed that tries to surface only what matters to you.

Right now I’m giving free access, and I’d genuinely appreciate feedback from anyone willing to try it out. I’m trying to improve the scoring, relevance, and overall experience before scaling it further.

If you try it, tell me:

  • does the feed actually feel relevant?
  • what’s missing?
  • what would make it something you’d actually use daily?

Happy to answer questions here too.

Try it here: Freyo

u/ArticleSilent7403 — 18 days ago