
Week 19: Tricolor - Neapolitan Calico Ice Cream Sandwiches
When discussing this theme on the Discord, u/mentaina mentioned that a calico cat is also known as a gatto tricolore in Italian. I love calico cats, and had just met a really friendly 23 year old (!) calico just down the road from me so felt inspired to make something to celebrate this beautiful coat patterning. I’ve made calico cat cookies for a previous baking theme, so wanted to do something a little bit different so u/Kauyon_Kais suggested making them into ice cream sandwiches. I thought this would be a really fun idea, and I could also use the famously three-coloured Neapolitan ice cream too.
I used this recipe for the cookies and dyed a small amount orange with food colouring, and a small amount brown using cocoa powder. I then rolled out the cookies and used little pieces of the orange and brown doughs and cut out cats using my set of cat cookie cutters. I decided that I needed a firm set on my ice cream and my no-churn recipe is quite soft, so I bought a tub of Neapolitan, left it to soften slightly before refreezing in narrower layers in a loaf tin. After the cookies were baked, I cut out slices of my Neapolitan ice cream and then stamped out cat shapes with my cookie cutters. The whole thing felt a bit like an assembly line, stamping out precise blocks and stacking together like LEGO blocks.
When assembling the ice cream sandwiches I realised that you could barely tell that the filling was also tricoloured, so I also put a couple of Neapolitan ice cream cats on the plate as well - luckily I took a picture quickly because they rapidly started to melt. These were good but I would probably use a different cookie next time. I chose a sugar cookie for the precision of cutting out into cat shapes, but I think a chewier, thicker cookie is a bit nicer in an ice cream sandwich.